← Back to the lab site The Water Path v8
Water Path · Map Journey Test yourself Feedback

A plant physiology learning tool

The water path

One molecule of water, from the soil to the sky, and everything a plant builds along the way. Each stop below is one topic, in order. Every number on this site carries a source, and every model says what it leaves out.

One molecule of water, soil to sky, in miniature. Most of it leaves through a stoma on the underside of a leaf; about 1 in 60 to 1 in 100 is split at photosystem II and becomes the oxygen and electrons of Light to sugar. Water potential becomes more negative along the way (soil −0.10, root −0.24, stem −0.36, leaf −0.57 MPa, air about −126 MPa). model journey and light defaults, not measurements; drawing and timing not to scale. Tap a part to open its plate.

Six plates

The journey: one molecule of water, soil to air, in six plates

Follow one molecule of water from the Salinas field to an aquaporin in a leaf cell membrane, and back out to the air. Set the afternoon once (crop, soil water, temperature, humidity, light) and every level answers. Choose your depth: 1 Explore for a first look, 2 Explain for the core ideas, 3 Expert with the equations, constants and the papers that disagree.

  1. Water I Fieldthe Salinas sky pulls: VPD, ETo, a day
  2. Water II Plantthe whole plant as one circuit, soil to air
  3. Water III Organroots, stem, petiole and vulnerability
  4. Water IV Tissueoutside the xylem: bundle sheath, palisade, spongy
  5. Water V Membraneaquaporins open and close
  6. Water VI California and beyondchaparral, oaks, desert roots and crops on the same axes
  7. ◆ Your Salinas afternoonrun a scenario and explain it

Start the journey

Five plates

Light to sugar: from the Sun to a sugar in six plates

Follow one photon for eight minutes from the Sun to a leaf, mix your own greenhouse light and see why it glows purple, watch photons channel down palisade cells or scatter in the spongy mesophyll of a real grapevine leaf, read a light response curve, then follow electrons, protons and the ATP synthase rotor in the thylakoid, and the Calvin Benson cycle spending what the light made. Same three depths as the journey, and every plate ends with Test yourself: Know it, Use it, Question it.

  1. Light I The Sunphotons, waves, LED recipes, phytochrome
  2. Light II The Leafa leaf as an optical device
  3. Light III The ThylakoidZ scheme, ETR, proton motive force, ATP
  4. Light IV The StromaRubisco, photorespiration, the FvCB model
  5. Light V Water for carbonevery CO2 costs water
  6. Light VI Three ways to fix carbonC3, C4 and CAM leaves in 3D

Start Light to sugar

Five plates

Sugar on the move: how sugar leaves the leaf and travels in the phloem

Follow the sugar made in Light to sugar out of the leaf. Watch it enter a minor vein through plasmodesmata, or through the cell wall with SWEET and SUT, or trapped as raffinose; then ride a sieve tube pushed by water pressure, through sieve plates, beside the xylem that supplies its water. Zoom, pan and turn the 3D scenes, change the sugar, the xylem and the path, and check the model against the plants it was measured in. Same three depths, and Test yourself on every plate.

  1. Sugar I The source leafloading: active, passive, polymer trap; sucrose and sorbitol
  2. Sugar II The sieve tubeMünch pressure flow, sieve plates, companion cells
  3. Sugar III Xylem meets phloemtwo pipes, one water supply
  4. Sugar IV Sinksroots, fruit and growing leaves
  5. Sugar V Under stressdrought, heat and recovery

Start Sugar on the move

Two plates, more coming

Curious things: plants that break the rules

Plants that dry out and come back to life, and roots that breathe under water, taken apart in 3D with every number sourced.

  1. Curious I Back from the deadresurrection plants dry to almost no water and recover
  2. Curious II Breathing underwateraerenchyma and the seal against oxygen loss

Open Curious things

Start here · one question, four figures, about five minutes

Why can a plant standing in wet soil still be in water stress?

Almost everything on this site hangs off that question, and you can get to the answer in four moves. Each link below opens one figure with one thing to do. Come back here after each one.

  1. Find out how hard the air pulls. Open Fig 5.1, the VPD calculator and press the Fresno chip, then the Salinas chip. The vapour pressure deficit goes from 4.82 kPa to 1.08 kPa. Same water in the soil either way; the sky is not the same.
  2. Now put a plant under that sky, with its roots in wet soil. Fig 5.4 opens on Fresno air with the soil at −0.030 MPa, which is as wet as it gets. Read the leaf Ψ at 14:00: −0.93 MPa, stomata 29 % open. Press Salinas without touching the soil: −0.46 MPa, 63 % open. That is the answer. Water moves down a difference in water potential, and the air sets the far end of it. Wet soil only fixes the near end.
  3. See what that tension costs. Fig 6.1 opens at −1.73 MPa on a grapevine imaged alive. Half the stem's conductivity is already gone, and 89 % of the petiole's. The plant does not get that back while it is under tension.
  4. Run it for a month. Fig F.1 opens on 28 hot dry days with no irrigation. Ten days without turgor, past P50 on day 19, 100 % loss of conductivity by the end. Then drag Irrigate every N days to 7 and watch all four numbers go back to nothing.

That is the spine of the Water Path: the sky pulls, the soil supplies, and the plant sits between them deciding how much to open. Everything else is the detail of how it does that. Now take the stops below in order: Stop 1 is the anatomy you need before any of the rest makes sense.

    Test yourselfKnow it · Use it · Question itFive questions a round. Scores stay in your browser.

    Built by Dr Caetano Albuquerque, with a review board on leaf hydraulics, grapevine water relations, xylem imaging and design. Works on a phone. Your progress and predictions stay in this browser only.

    Map › Anatomy

    Stop 1 of 7 · Anatomy

    Read a section

    Four organs, the same three tissue systems. Root, stem, leaf and petiole are all built from dermal, ground and vascular tissue, arranged differently. Knowing where each one sits is what lets you read any section, a micrograph or a scan.

    See the sections

    The animation above follows water across a young root in cross section. More sections are on the journey plates: a root and a leaf midrib in Water III, Organ, and a leaf around a minor vein in Water IV, Tissue. Test yourself on this stop checks the three tissue systems and where each one sits.

    Map › Water and turgor

    Stop 2 of 7 · Water potential and turgor

    Turgor through a Salinas day

    One cell losing water, one leaf across one day, one plant across a week without irrigation. Solutes mostly set the water potential at which a cell loses turgor; the wall sets how much water it loses getting there.

    Original module

    Reviewed by a six-person board. Its charts are small on a phone; open it full screen and turn the phone sideways. The osmotic adjustment and plant drawing on the Demand page use the same equations in the new style.

    Map › Growth

    Stop 3 of 7 · Growth

    Why a plant grows at night

    A cell grows by pushing on its wall until the wall yields. Take a little turgor away and growth stops, long before anything looks wilted. That makes growth the most sensitive readout of water status a plant has.

    Before you start: the growth equation in words
    GR = φ (Ψp − Y)
    Lockhart 1965. Growth rate equals wall extensibility times the turgor in excess of a yield threshold. Below the threshold, nothing grows.
    Turgor pressure, positive inside a living cell.
    The yield threshold: the turgor the wall needs before it stretches for good. The cell can move it.
    Extensibility: how readily the wall gives once turgor is above Y.
    Fig 4.1

    Lockhart, with one modelled day of turgor

    Where does the yield threshold have to sit for this plant to grow at night and not at midday?

    0.1no verified leaf value yet1.2 MPa
    Turgor on day 1 of drying, modelled
    • Drag Y between the two dots: the plant grows only at night.
    • Switch to the adjusted leaf: the same leaf water potentials now carry more turgor, so the midday dot can clear the threshold.
    • Push Y above both dots: no growth at all, without a single wilted leaf.
    Check itsources, and what the model leaves outDERIVEDILLUSTRATIVE

    Turgor solved from the pressure volume equations with the crop parameters of Bartlett et al. 2012 (πo −0.95 MPa, ε 5 MPa) at the day 1 predawn and midday leaf water potentials of the seven day drying figure (−0.06 and −0.50 MPa). The adjusted leaf shifts its turgor loss point by the global mean of Bartlett et al. 2014, −0.44 MPa across 283 wild and crop species (abstract), from −1.17 to −1.61 MPa; at ε 5 MPa that is πo −1.22 MPa (Bartlett et al. 2012 Eq. 1). DERIVED Y and φ ILLUSTRATIVE. Sources

    Green, Erickson and Buggy lowered the turgor of a growing Nitella cell by 0.7 atmosphere (0.07 MPa). Growth stopped. Fifteen minutes later it started again, at the lower turgor. What changed?

    Your prediction
    Fig 4.2

    What stops first as a plant dries

    Growth, photosynthesis, or a grower's irrigation trigger: which sits closest to wet?

    • Lettuce growers irrigate when the soil is still at −0.015 to −0.035 MPa. That is 40 to 100 times wetter than the textbook wilting point of −1.5 MPa.
    • In corn, soybean and sunflower, leaf enlargement was already strongly inhibited by −0.4 MPa of leaf water potential.
    • In soybean, photosynthesis held until about −1.1 MPa (−11 bars). In corn it was inhibited whenever leaf water potential was more negative than −0.35 MPa (−3.5 bars); that value is not plotted on the chart.
    Check itsources, and what the model leaves out

    Boyer 1970 Plant Physiol 46: 233 and 46: 236 (photosynthesis thresholds as stated in the abstract of 46: 236 MEASURED); Cahn & Farrara, UCCE Monterey tensiometer guide; Cahn et al. 2022 Horticulturae 8: 857; Richards & Weaver 1944 for −1.5 MPa, the conventional wilting point. Soil and leaf values are on different axes of the plant and are shown together only to compare magnitudes.

    Check itwhat this stop assumes, and what it leaves out
    What is not here, and why

    No measured day and night leaf growth trace for a crop is on this page, because we have not yet read one from a primary source. When we have Schultz and Matthews (1993) for grapevine or a Tardieu maize record in hand, it goes here and the argument in Fig 4.1 goes from conditional to demonstrated.

    Go deeperreadings, methods, and what is still argued

    Map › Demand

    Stop 4 of 7 · Demand

    The sky pulls

    Air is the driest thing a plant touches. How hard it pulls depends on temperature and humidity together, through the vapour pressure deficit. Wet soil does not protect a plant from a thirsty sky, and that is the core of the Denmead and Shaw result.

    Before you start: four quantities and one unit
    Saturation vapour pressure: the most water vapour the air can hold at that temperature. It climbs steeply with temperature.
    Actual vapour pressure: how much it is holding. Relative humidity is ea ÷ es.
    = es − ea
    The gap. This is what pulls water out of a leaf, a towel or a lettuce head.
    Volumetric soil water content, cubic centimetres of water per cubic centimetre of soil.
    kPa
    Kilopascals. VPD is small numbers in kPa; water potential is in MPa. 1 MPa = 1000 kPa = 10 bar. A tensiometer's 30 cbar is 30 kPa, or −0.03 MPa.

    Start hereDrag the temperature slider in Fig 5.1 and leave humidity alone. VPD grows even though the relative humidity never changed. That is why warmer air dries plants out even when it holds more water.

    Fig 5.1

    The VPD calculator

    How much harder does a Fresno afternoon pull than a Salinas afternoon?

    July afternoon
    More controls: leaf temperature

    What a leaf actually feels is the leaf to air VPD: es at leaf temperature minus ea of the air. A leaf three degrees warmer than the air, which happens when stomata close and transpiration stops cooling it, faces about 40 per cent more pull at 20 °C and 50 % humidity. The increase is larger in cool humid air and smaller in hot dry air.

    • Hold humidity at 50 per cent and slide from 20 to 35 °C: VPD goes from 1.2 to 2.8 kPa. Same relative humidity, more than twice the pull.
    • Watch the air water potential tile. Even 99 per cent humidity is about −1.4 MPa, drier than a well-watered leaf.
    • Fresno at 36.5 °C and 21 per cent against Salinas at 21.5 °C and an estimated 58 per cent: about 4.8 against 1.1 kPa.
    Check itsources, and what the model leaves outMEASUREDDERIVED

    Data behind the presets

    JulyMean maxMean minAfternoon RHVPD
    Fresno (FAT)36.5 °C20.7 °C21 %4.8 kPa
    Salinas (airport)21.5 °C12.8 °C58 % est.1.1 kPa

    Fresno: NWS Hanford 1991 to 2020 normals; afternoon RH from NOAA Comparative Climatic Data MEASURED. Salinas: NOAA 1991 to 2020 normals via secondary copy; no humidity normals exist for Salinas, so the afternoon humidity is estimated with FAO-56 Eq. 48, taking the night minimum as the dew point DERIVED · ESTIMATE. To be replaced with CIMIS Salinas North station humidity. The marine layer morning preset is a typical foggy coastal morning chosen for teaching, not a station record. ILLUSTRATIVE

    es = 0.6108 exp[17.27 T ÷ (T + 237.3)] kPa, FAO-56 Eq. 11 (Allen et al. 1998). Air water potential Ψ = (RT ÷ V̄w) ln(RH), with RT ÷ V̄w = 135 MPa at 20 °C. PHYSICS Sources

    Before you press Fresno: a July afternoon in Fresno is 15 °C hotter than in Salinas. How many times harder does the Fresno air pull on a leaf?

    Your prediction
    Fig 5.2

    The towel on the line, in numbers

    Reference evapotranspiration by month: how much water a well-watered grass surface loses.

    Compare with Fresno State
    • The Salinas Valley is not one climate. July ETo climbs from 4.0 inches at Castroville to 6.5 at Soledad as the fog thins inland.
    • Salinas North peaks in June, not July. The July and August marine layer cuts demand.
    Check itsources, and what the model leaves outMEASURED

    CIMIS station averages, California Code of Regulations Title 23, Model Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance, Appendix A (inches per month). MEASURED · CIMIS

    Denmead and Shaw, 1962

    Corn in 136 containers sunk in an Iowa field, black plastic over the soil so every lost gram was transpiration, soil water read every day by neutron probe. They asked a simple question: at what soil water content does a plant stop keeping up with the air? The answer was that it depends on the air.

    Fig 5.3

    The wilting point moves with the weather

    Soil tension at which actual transpiration fell below the potential rate, for days of different evaporative demand.

    • On high demand days (6.4 mm per day) the corn fell behind at 0.3 bar, almost field capacity. On overcast days (1.4 mm per day) it kept up until 12 bars.
    • Same soil, same crop, same summer: a factor of forty.
    • The mechanism: soil conductivity falls steeply as soil dries, so at high flux a steep gradient opens between soil and root, leaf water potential becomes more negative, stomata close, and transpiration falls below the potential rate.
    Check itsources, and what the model leaves outMEASURED

    All three points are stated in the body of the paper, p. 387, and redrawn for this site. The middle one is plotted at 3.3 mm per day, which is the labelled curve in their Figures 3 and 4; the text phrases that rate as "3 to 4 mm. per day". The high-demand point is plotted at 6.4, which is both the labelled curve and the rate the text gives; the paper's own Synopsis rounds it to "6 to 7". Denmead & Shaw 1962 Agron J 54: 385. MEASURED · REDRAWN The paper plots soil suction, its word for tension, on a different axis; here drier soil is further down the chart.

    Fig 5.4

    Two plants, one day

    Same soil, same sky, same leaf water potential. Plant B has loaded solutes through the season. Scrub the day: when do the stomata close, when do the leaves droop, and when do they grow?

    midnight06noon18midnight
    The air
    VPD, computed from the air

    Set the air yourself: temperature and humidity

    A town chip loads that station's four numbers here. Move any slider and the chips switch to your own air, and the plant, the stomata and the growth readouts all follow it.

    5 °C2545 °C
    0 °C1530 °C
    20 %60100 %
    5 %50100 %

    There are two standard ways to get ea, and they are not the same equation. With measured humidities you use FAO-56 Eq. 17, the two-humidity form, which is what these sliders use. With no humidity data you take the night minimum as a dew point and use Eq. 48, which is what the two town chips use, because neither station publishes humidity normals. The humidities a chip loads here are that station's own dew point converted back into a dawn and an afternoon value, so the two routes land within about half a per cent of each other in ea once the slider has rounded them to whole per cent. With humidities measured independently of the temperature they would not have to agree at all.

    −0.03 wet−0.17−1.0 MPa dry
    More controls: season and yield threshold
    • Salinas, wet soil: scrub from 05:00 to 14:00. The stomata open with the light, leaf water potential becomes more negative, turgor dips, and both plants keep growing, fastest at night.
    • Switch to Fresno and drag the soil to −0.5 MPa. By mid afternoon the stomata are mostly shut and plant A has lost all its turgor and droops. Plant B, same water potential, still has turgor.
    • Watch the evening: turgor comes back over hours, not instantly, because the plant has to refill its own tissues. That is when the leaves expand.
    • Compare hours of growth and hours without turgor in the status line, not the growth rates: both plants share one yield threshold, which exaggerates B's speed.
    Check itsources, and what the model leaves outDERIVEDILLUSTRATIVE

    What this model leaves out

      Weather: July normals (Salinas 21.5 / 12.8 °C, Fresno 36.5 / 20.7 °C), sine by day and exponential decay by night after Parton & Logan 1981, dew point held constant (Salinas estimated as the night minimum, FAO-56 Eq. 48; Fresno from 21 % afternoon humidity), VPD from FAO-56 Eq. 11, sunrise and sunset computed for 15 July DERIVED. Air you set yourself takes ea from the two humidities by FAO-56 Eq. 17 instead, through the same code the season figure uses. Stomatal closure with leaf Ψ: half closed at −0.60 MPa, fitted to Albuquerque et al. 2020 Table 2; night conductance 10 % of day (Caird et al. 2007; Dayer et al. 2021). Turgor from the pressure volume equations (ε 5 MPa). Plant B: πo becomes more negative by 0.0045 MPa per day, from −1.00 to −1.40 (Farolfi et al. 2025; Martorell et al. 2015). Conductance, capacitance, Y and φ ILLUSTRATIVE. MODEL OUTPUT · NOT DATA

      Same plant, same soil, same yield threshold: the sky is what decides whether it grows today.

      Fresno, soil at −0.5 MPa, 15:00. Both plants have the same leaf water potential. Which one has lost all its turgor?

      Your prediction
      The grapevine finding behind plant B

      In grapevine this adjustment follows the calendar, not the soil. Potted Pinot noir lowered its osmotic potential by about 0.005 MPa per day across the season. Water deficit added only 0.03 MPa in one greenhouse season, not significant, and 0.07 to 0.09 MPa in the next (P < 0.001); at most 0.10 MPa overall (Farolfi et al. 2025). Well-watered Tempranillo adjusted as much as stressed vines: 0.37 against 0.31 MPa in πo, June to August (Martorell et al. 2015). That is why plant B's control is weeks since budbreak, not soil water. Plant A is a hypothetical control: only 13 to 15 per cent of wild species show no adjustment (Bartlett et al. 2014).

      Real seasonal data behind plant B
      Materialπo earlyπo lateπtlp earlyπtlp lateSource
      Tempranillo, water stressed, Jun → Aug−1.13−1.44−1.46−2.01Martorell 2015, Table 3
      Tempranillo, well watered, Jun → Aug−0.95−1.32−1.33−1.76Martorell 2015, Table 3
      Pinot noir, 5-year-old vines in 43 L pots outdoors, 75 to 145 days−1.23−1.57··Farolfi 2025
      Syrah, Davis, Jul → Sep−1.05−1.73··Sinclair 2024, Table 1
      Merlot, Davis, Jul → Sep−1.48−2.23··Sinclair 2024, Table 1
      Global mean shift in πtlpnot reported in the abstract−0.44Bartlett et al. 2014, 283 species
      Check itwhat this stop assumes, and what it leaves out
      Caveat · how to read a classic

      The corn was in containers 24 inches deep, so roots could not explore. Ritchie (1973) found field corn in a weighing lysimeter used at least 80 per cent of its extractable water before transpiration dropped. The direction of the effect is not in dispute; the size of it in an unrestricted root zone is. Teach the mechanism, not the thresholds.

      Go deeperreadings, methods, and what is still argued
      Open question · in your backyard

      No pressure volume curve for lettuce has been published in a major journal that we could find. Its osmotic potential, turgor loss point and wall stiffness are unmeasured in a crop worth billions to this valley. A vapour pressure osmometer gives πo from a leaf disc in ten minutes.

      Map › Embolism

      Stop 5 of 7 · Embolism

      When the column breaks

      In a transpiring plant, water in the xylem is pulled from above, and a pulled column can fail. A bubble enters, a conduit fills with gas, and that lane of the highway closes. How much tension a plant can take before it loses its lanes is one of the best predictors of whether it survives a drought.

      Before you start: the words that get mixed up
      The event: water under tension breaks and a gas void forms in a conduit.
      The state that follows: a conduit full of gas that no longer carries water.
      How it usually starts: air is pulled from an already embolised conduit through a pore in the pit membrane into a working neighbour.
      Percent loss of conductivity, 100 × (1 − K ÷ Kmax).
      The xylem water potentials at 12, 50 and 88 per cent loss of conductivity: first air entry, half the conductivity, nearly all.

      Start hereDrag the xylem water potential in Fig 6.1 from 0 toward −3 MPa. The petiole loses its conductivity first and the stem holds on. Then read Fig 6.2 to see what the leaf has already done by the time either one starts.

      Fig 6.1

      Vulnerability curves of a real grapevine

      Cabernet Sauvignon imaged alive: how much conductivity is gone at a given tension?

      Show P12, P50, P88 for
      Build your own curve

      P12 = P50 + 50 ÷ s and P88 = P50 − 50 ÷ s. A steep curve puts all three close together; a shallow one spreads them out.

      • At −1.2 MPa the petiole has lost about two thirds of its conductivity and the stem about a tenth. The cheaper organ fails first, a pattern called vulnerability segmentation. This petiole curve is one of the least negative imaging values: its P50 comes after stomatal conductance has halved but before stomata are 80 % closed, and before midrib embolism in Fig 6.2, one reason the petiole numbers are argued over.
      • The shaded band is the stem P50 range across 30 grape varieties: −1.8 to −3.4 MPa. The variety matters as much as the method.
      • The tick marks under the axis are the midday stem water potential classes growers use. "Severe" begins at −1.4 MPa, just short of stem P50.
      Check itsources, and what the model leaves outMEASUREDSECONDARY

      Curves: PLC = 100 ÷ (1 + exp[(s ÷ 25)(Ψ − P50)]), Pammenter & Vander Willigen 1998, with P50 and slope from Charrier et al. 2016 Plant Physiol 172: 1657, Table I (stem −1.73 MPa, 98.4 % per MPa; petiole −0.98 MPa, 69.3 % per MPa), in vivo synchrotron microCT MEASURED. Band: Lamarque et al. 2023 Sci Rep 13: 7724, Cavitron MEASURED. Stem water potential classes: van Leeuwen et al. 2009, via Myburgh & Howell 2022 SECONDARY. Sources

      Fig 6.2

      The order of failure in a grapevine leaf

      As water potential becomes more negative, what goes first: the pipes, the stomata, or the living cells?

      Predict before you look: in a drying grapevine leaf, which of these happens first?

      Your prediction

      Check itsources, and what the model leaves outMEASURED

      Ranges span cultivars and seasons. Steps 1 to 3: Albuquerque et al. 2020, Table 2 (Cabernet Sauvignon, Chardonnay). Step 4: Albuquerque 2020 gs P80, Dayer et al. 2020 canopy 90 % closure, Hochberg et al. 2017. Step 5: Albuquerque 2020, Dayer 2020, Martorell 2015. Steps 6 and 7: Albuquerque 2020 midrib onset, Dayer 2020 optical P12 and P50. Step 8: Charrier et al. 2016 and Lamarque et al. 2023. In unirrigated vines, turgor loss, stomatal closure and leaf P50 each moved 0.7 to 0.95 MPa more negative between May and August (Sorek et al. 2021). MEASURED · RANGES

      Fig 6.3

      The hydraulic safety margin

      How close does a vine run to its own P50 on the driest afternoon of the year?

      Stem vulnerability
      • Across 226 forest species at 81 sites, 70 per cent run with a safety margin under 1 MPa, whatever the rainfall where they grow (Choat et al. 2012).
      • Conifers that passed about 50 per cent loss of stem conductivity did not recover; angiosperm trees failed near 88 per cent. That is why P88 is the angiosperm line.
      • Push the seasonal minimum to −1.4 MPa, the start of "severe" for growers: the potted Cabernet Sauvignon margin is only 0.3 MPa.
      Check itsources, and what the model leaves outDERIVED

      HSM = Ψmin − P50 and Ψmin − P88, Choat et al. 2012 Nature 491: 752. Death thresholds: Brodribb & Cochard 2009 Plant Physiol 149: 575 (conifers); Urli et al. 2013 Tree Physiol 33: 672 (angiosperms). The two variety curves use the Lamarque range endpoints with the Charrier stem slope, DERIVED.

      Fig 6.4

      Why wide vessels matter most

      Tap vessels to embolise them. Compare the share you counted, the share of area, and the share of flow.

      • Embolise the three widest: under a fifth of the vessels by count, well over half the flow.
      • Embolise the eight narrowest: half the vessels by count, a few per cent of the flow.
      • Tracing gas-filled conduits on an image measures area, the middle tile. That is closer to PLC than counting, but still not PLC.
      Check itsources, and what the model leaves outILLUSTRATIVE

      Hagen-Poiseuille: flow through one tube scales with D⁴, so doubling the diameter multiplies flow by 16. Theoretical PLC = 100 × ΣD⁴ embolised ÷ ΣD⁴ all, the approach used with microCT by Brodersen et al. 2013. Vessel diameters here span 22 to 110 µm ILLUSTRATIVE.

      Fig 6.5

      The pit membrane sets the breaking point

      How much tension does it take to pull an air bubble through a pore of a given size?

      • Halve the pore and the plant can take twice the tension before air gets through. Under the air-seeding hypothesis, the largest pit membrane pore in the vessel wall sets the breaking point.
      • In sugar maple, soaking vessels in oxalic acid, which strips calcium from the pit membranes, made them 95 per cent embolised at −2.0 MPa against −4.0 MPa in controls. Weaken the membrane and the breaking point halves.
      • Something to check with the equation: Sperry and Tyree saw maple pit membrane pores of 0.4 µm or less and judged that consistent with air seeding. Most maple vessels embolised only at xylem pressures more negative than −3 MPa, and by ΔP = 4T ÷ D that pressure difference matches a pore of about 0.1 µm. The equation is the mechanism, not a measuring tool; pore sizes seen after preparing membranes for microscopy may not be the pores air actually uses.
      Check itsources, and what the model leaves out

      ΔP = 4T ÷ D, with the surface tension of water at 20 °C, T = 0.0728 N m⁻¹ (4T = 0.291 N m⁻¹, as in Figs E.1 and E.3), and a contact angle of zero. Sperry & Tyree 1988 Plant Physiol 88: 581. PHYSICS

      Salinas Valley · lettuce

      We do not yet have a verified vulnerability curve for lettuce, wheat, maize or sunflower that we are willing to plot. Herbs are not automatically more vulnerable than trees: 26 herbaceous species spanned P50 from −0.5 to −7.5 MPa (Lens et al. 2016).

      Check itwhat this stop assumes, and what it leaves out
      Caveat · one number is never "the" P50

      Published grapevine petiole values disagree: −0.98 MPa here, −1.54 MPa by MRI in Syrah (Hochberg et al. 2016). Stem P50 moved from −2.07 MPa in July to −2.82 MPa in September in four-year-old vines measured with a Cavitron (Charrier et al. 2018). Plant age, pot or field, season, cultivar and method each move P50 by up to a megapascal. Short-segment air injection put grapevine stems at more than 90 % loss of conductivity by −0.5 MPa, and flushed centrifuge stems by −1.5 MPa. Bench dehydration and long-segment air injection showed no significant embolism at water potentials less negative than −2.0 MPa, and MRI showed most vessels still water-filled at water potentials less negative than −1.5 MPa. Choat et al. concluded that those two bench methods suit long-vesselled organs like grapevine stems (Choat et al. 2010; Cochard et al. 2013).

      Go deeperreadings, methods, and what is still argued

      How do we know? Methods and fights

      • Imaging a living plant. Synchrotron microCT sees gas-filled conduits in an intact plant without cutting it. Brodersen and colleagues watched embolism in grapevine stems start near the pith around −1.2 MPa and spread from vessel to vessel within sectors: only 16 of 629 connections, about 2.5 %, were lateral, into a neighbouring sector.
      • The open vessel problem. Grapevine vessels can be longer than the segment you spin in a centrifuge. Cut them open and the curve bends into an "r" shape that makes the plant look far more vulnerable than it is.
      • Refilling. Brodersen et al. 2010 filmed vessels refilling in intact grapevines, but only vessels hydraulically isolated from working neighbours. Knipfer et al. 2016 saw fast refilling in cut stems supplied with free water. Whether intact vines refill under tension is still argued. In intact vines, "refilling was not observed as long as bulk xylem pressure remained negative" (Charrier et al. 2016). Refilling happens when pressure is near zero or positive: root pressure at night, or rain.
      • Wilting is not embolism. A lettuce that recovers overnight has recovered turgor in its living cells. That says nothing about whether embolised conduits refilled.

      Map › Embolism › How a conduit fails

      Enrichment · after Stop 5 · Embolism

      How a conduit fails

      A vulnerability curve is a summary. Underneath it there is one pore, a few hundred nanometres across, somewhere in a pit membrane you cannot see in any image we take. This page takes that pore apart: what sets its breaking pressure, what conifers grew to shut it, and why "wide conduits are vulnerable" is a statement about counting, not about lumens.

      Before you start: the words on this page
      The porous sheet of cell wall left between two neighbouring conduits where the thick secondary wall is absent. Water crosses it; air is supposed not to.
      The mouth on each side of the pit, where the overarching wall leaves an opening into the conduit.
      In conifers only: a thick, solid disc in the middle of the pit membrane. It carries no pores.
      In conifers only: the open web of strands around the torus. Almost all of the water goes through it.
      The valve closing: pressure difference pushes the torus sideways until it seats on one aperture and plugs it.
      Air pulled from a gas-filled conduit through the largest pore of the pit membrane into a working neighbour.
      The idea that a conduit fails at the pressure of its single leakiest pore, so more pit area means more chances at a bad one.
      Sector
      A wedge of the stem cross-section, running from the pith outwards. Vessels in one wedge are connected to each other far more than to the wedge next door.
      Percolation
      Anything spreading through a network by moving from one occupied place to a touching empty one. Here: air moving from a gas-filled vessel into a water-filled neighbour.

      Start hereDrag the pore in Fig E.1 down to 30 nm and back up to 1000 nm and watch the pressure. Then find the pore, the vessel and the microCT voxel on the same scale bar. Everything else on this page follows from that one picture, and Fig E.7 puts all of it into one stem you can dry with a Play button.

      Fig E.1

      Air seeding, live

      One pore, one surface tension, one pressure. How big is the thing that decides?

      30 nm1003161000 nm
      • The teaching point. The pore that decides whether a vessel lives is about 1/25 of the vessel's width, and it is far smaller than one voxel of the microCT scans on this site. It is invisible in the images. We infer it from a pressure.
      • The unit-safe shortcut. D(µm) = 0.291 ÷ ΔP(MPa), and the same equation the other way, ΔP(MPa) = 0.291 ÷ D(µm). A 291 nm pore breaks at exactly −1 MPa. Halve the pore, double the pressure it takes.
      • Run it backwards on a real number: grapevine stem P50 is −1.73 MPa, so the pore that would explain it is 0.291 ÷ 1.73 = 168 nm. Nobody has ever seen that pore in that vessel.
      Check itsources, and what the model leaves outDERIVEDMEASURED

      ΔP = 4T ÷ D with the surface tension of water T = 0.0728 N m⁻¹ at 20 °C and a contact angle of zero, so 4T = 0.2912 N m⁻¹ and ΔP in MPa = 0.2912 ÷ D in µm. Computed pressure DERIVED. Pore 0.4 µm: the upper end of the pit membrane pore diameters measured by scanning electron microscopy in Acer saccharum (0.4 µm or less), Sperry & Tyree 1988 Plant Physiol 88: 581 MEASURED. Vessel 9.95 µm: mean vessel diameter of Syrah grapevine petioles, 9.95 ± 0.53 µm, Hochberg et al. 2016 Plant Cell Environ 39: 1886 MEASURED. Voxel 1.27 µm: the voxel of the leaf midrib scans used on this site MEASURED. Fig 6.5 in the Embolism stop uses the same 20 °C value; the air seeding theatres use T = 0.072 N m⁻¹ (water at 25 °C), and the 1 % difference changes no conclusion here. Sources, Hochberg et al. 2016

      Fig E.2

      Two ways to build a pit membrane

      An angiosperm has a sieve. A conifer has a valve. What does the valve buy, and what does it cost?

      Pit architecture

      • The conifer valve. Once the pressure difference across the pit passes a threshold (drawn here at 1 MPa, a round teaching number ILLUSTRATIVE), the torus is pushed sideways until it seats on the aperture and plugs it. The embolised tracheid is isolated; its water-filled neighbour keeps working. Push the slider past 1 MPa with the conifer selected and watch it close.
      • The angiosperm has no valve. The homogeneous membrane only stretches. When the pressure difference beats the largest pore, air comes through, and the neighbour embolises too.
      • The trade-off. The torus-margo valve lets conifers isolate an embolised tracheid. It does not make the pit a bottleneck: torus-margo end-wall pits had about 59 times lower flow resistance per area than angiosperm vessel pits (Pittermann et al. 2005). Conifers pay instead through their conduits, tracheids that are short and narrow, so water must cross many end walls; the pits make up for it, and tracheids and vessels of the same diameter ended up with similar resistivity.
      Check itsources, and what the model leaves outSECONDARYILLUSTRATIVE

      Architecture, aspiration and the efficiency comparison: Pittermann J, Sperry JS, Hacke UG, Wheeler JK, Sikkema EH (2005) Torus-margo pits help conifers compete with angiosperms. Science 310: 1924 SECONDARY. Caveat: the page number of this citation was not independently verified in this build; the authors, year, journal and volume are. The drawing is a schematic cross-section, not to scale and not traced from a micrograph ILLUSTRATIVE. The 1 MPa aspiration threshold is a round teaching number, not a measured constant for any species. Sources

      Fig E.3

      The rare pit hypothesis

      If a conduit fails at its single worst pore, what does making the conduit bigger do?

      Predict before you drag: you double the pit membrane area of a conduit and change nothing about the pores themselves. What happens to the pressure at which that conduit embolises?

      Your prediction
      0.5 mm²102030 mm²

      • The top panel is the pore-size distribution. It never moves. The only thing the slider changes is how many pores you draw from it.
      • The bottom panel is what you would measure: a population of conduits, each failing at its own worst pore. The grey outline is the same population at the smallest pit area, kept for comparison.
      • That is the whole hypothesis. Vulnerability is not a property of the lumen. It is an extreme-value statistic on the pit membranes, and area is the number of tickets you bought.
      Check itsources, and what the model leaves outILLUSTRATIVE

      ILLUSTRATIVE This is a demonstration of a mechanism, not a fit to data. Pore diameters are drawn from a lognormal distribution with median 0.040 µm and log standard deviation 0.45, at 200 candidate pores per mm² of pit membrane; all three constants are invented to put the output in a plausible range. The largest of N draws is computed exactly, not by looping. Each conduit's failure pressure is then ΔP = 4T ÷ Dmax. Hypothesis and evidence: Wheeler, Sperry, Hacke & Hoang 2005 Plant, Cell & Environment 28: 800; Christman, Sperry & Adler 2009 New Phytologist. Sources

      Fig E.4

      Thirteen measured P50 values, one axis

      Put grapevine, almond, tomato, soybean, blue oak and juniper on the same axis. Which lose half their conductivity at the least negative water potential?

      Method filter
        • Every row carries its organ, its method and its paper. There is no such thing as a species P50.
        • Where the published slope is not known, the curve is drawn with s = 50 % per MPa. The P50 is still the measured number; the shape around it is a guess, and each row says which it is.
        • Blue oak appears three times from one study. Those three curves are the same stems, one lab, three methods. Fig E.5 pulls them out on their own.
        Check itsources, and what the model leaves outMEASUREDILLUSTRATIVE

        Curves: PLC = 100 ÷ (1 + exp[(s ÷ 25)(Ψ − P50)]), Pammenter & Vander Willigen 1998. Grapevine slopes (98.4 and 69.3 % per MPa) from Charrier et al. 2016 Table I MEASURED; every other slope is s = 50 ILLUSTRATIVE SHAPE. Sources, in row order: Charrier et al. 2016 Plant Physiol 172: 1657; Hochberg, Albuquerque et al. 2016 Plant Cell Environ 39: 1886; Álvarez-Maldini et al. 2022 Front Plant Sci 13: 974050; Paudel et al. 2020 Tree Physiol 40: 454; Andrade et al. 2024 Physiol Plant 176: e14408; Schell et al. 2025 Plant Cell Environ 49: 4027; Pratt et al. 2020 Tree Physiol 40: 5; Willson, Manos & Jackson 2008 Am J Bot 95: 299. Sources

        Fig E.5

        One species, one lab, three methods

        Blue oak, the same one-year-old stems. How far apart can three methods put P50?

        A P50 without an organ, a method and a season is not a number.

        Check itsources, and what the model leaves outMEASURED

        Blue oak, Quercus douglasii, one-year-old stems: benchtop dehydration −3.22 MPa, optical −5.60 MPa, microCT −6.46 MPa. Across the stem ages and methods reported in that one study, P50 spans −2.19 to −6.46 MPa. Pratt RB, Castro V, Fickle JC, Jacobsen AL (2020) Tree Physiology 40: 5 MEASURED. Sources

        Fig E.6

        Embolism spreads in sectors, not at random

        A vine dries. Where in the cross-section does the air actually turn up?

        Predict before you drag. A grapevine stem dries until about a quarter of its vessels are gas-filled. Where are they?

        Your prediction
        0−1−2−3 MPa
        Spread rule

        • Do this. Drag down to −1.45 MPa, where a quarter of the vessels have gone. Count the sectors. Then switch the spread rule to At random without touching the slider. The same number of vessels is gas-filled either way; only the arrangement changes, and it goes from three sectors to ten.
        • The rule, in one sentence. Start at one vessel beside the pith. At every step, move into a vessel that touches one already gas-filled, staying inside the same sector unless a 2.5 % draw sends it sideways. The purple links mark the sideways steps; the dashed ring marks where it started.
        • Where this toy is unfair to itself. Each sector here holds only five vessels, so once a sector is full the spread has nowhere to go but sideways, and the run ends up crossing on about a fifth of its steps rather than 2.5 %. A real stem has far more vessels per sector, and new gas-filled vessels also appear beside the pith on their own account, which the toy does not do. The 2.5 % is applied honestly at every step where there is a genuine choice; the total is a consequence of the grid.
        • The curve has a toe. The count comes from the grapevine stem vulnerability curve, and a fitted sigmoid puts its first vessel at about −0.5 MPa, well short of the −1.2 MPa at which the imaging actually first saw air. That gap is what fitting a smooth curve to a threshold process costs you. It is not a disagreement about when air enters.
        Check itsources, and what the model leaves outILLUSTRATIVEMEASUREDDERIVED

        The drawing. A stylised cross-section: 12 identical sectors of 5 identical vessels around a central pith ILLUSTRATIVE. Grapevine xylem is not laid out on a grid, vessels are not all the same width, and vessels run and end along the stem as well as across it. The grid exists so that a sector and a ring can be counted, and for no other reason. The numbers. Vitis vinifera stems imaged live by synchrotron X-ray microCT while drying: embolism formed first in the vessels surrounding the pith at about −1.2 MPa stem water potential and spread radially within sectored vessel groupings; spread into an adjacent sector occurred in 16 of 629 connections. Brodersen et al. 2013 Plant Physiol 161: 1820 MEASURED. The rule. The percolation rule above is a teaching simplification of that one statistic, not a model of the mechanism: which vessel embolises next really depends on which vessels share pit membranes, on vessel length, and on where the vessel ends sit, and none of that is in this drawing. The count. How many vessels are gas-filled at a given water potential is read off the grapevine stem curve used in Fig E.4, P50 −1.73 MPa and slope 98.4 % per MPa, Charrier et al. 2016 Plant Physiol 172: 1657 DERIVED: a different study from Brodersen, on the same species and the same organ. Sources

        Predict before you use Fig E.7. In the model below, sectors are separated by rays, and vessels across a ray share very little pit wall. Raise that contact from 5 % to 50 %. What happens?

        Your prediction
        Fig E.7

        Dry a stem and the curve draws itself

        Three rules and no curve typed in: air gets through only the largest pore of a shared pit field, only from a neighbour that already holds gas, and it starts beside the pith. What comes out?

        0−1−2−3 MPa
        Where air gets in
        lessas drawnmore
        1 %20 %100 %

        • Watch the order. Orange lines are the route the air took, vessel to vessel; purple lines are the rare steps across a ray. The air works outward from the pith inside its own sector, as Brodersen and colleagues filmed in living grapevine.
        • The red curve was never typed in. It is what you get by asking, for every vessel, at what tension the air can first reach it. Compare it with the dotted measured curve: similar P50, steeper. A single cross-section with no vessel length is one reason.
        • Tap a vessel. The panel shows the one pore that decides it, and often the answer is that the pore that decides it is upstream: the door is open, but the air has not arrived yet.
        • Drag Pit area up and the whole curve moves toward zero without a single pore getting bigger. That is the rare pit hypothesis as a number you can watch.
        • We picked the stem that opens. It is number 2 of 40, chosen because its first air, −1.22 MPa, lands near the −1.2 MPa that was imaged. Across all 40 stems P50 runs from −1.68 to −1.93 MPa, first air from −0.84 to −1.25, and ray crossings from 2.5 to 9.2 % of steps. Press New stem and see.
        Check itsources, and what the model leaves outMEASUREDDERIVEDILLUSTRATIVESECONDARY

        A model, not a measurement ILLUSTRATIVE. Its sources, generated from the model's own source strings:

          What this model leaves out

            What this changes about the number you quote

            • A P50 is an emergent statistic, not a material property. It comes out of a distribution of pore sizes, a pit area, and a measurement method. Two of those three are not in the number.
            • Structure sets the ceiling, not the value. A conifer with a working torus can hold pressures an angiosperm cannot, and pays for it in conductivity. Within angiosperms, the fight is over pore size distributions and pit area.
            • You cannot see the pore. Not in the synchrotron microCT images on this site, not in a benchtop microCT, not in a standard light micrograph after preparation. The equation is a mechanism you reason with, not an instrument.
            • A curve is a count, not a map. Two stems at 25 % loss can look completely different in cross-section. The curve cannot tell them apart, and which one you have decides whether the remaining water still has a route to the leaves.
            Check itwhat this stop assumes, and what it leaves out

            No stop-level caveats beyond those inside each figure's own Check it.

            Go deeperreadings, methods, and what is still argued
            Salinas Valley · the gap that is still open

            We found no published vulnerability curve for lettuce. Every crop on this page that has one got it from somebody choosing a method, an organ and a season and writing all three down. That is the work, and it is not hard to do badly.

            Map › Where does the water actually leave?

            Stop 6 of 7 · Inside the leaf

            Where does the water actually leave?

            Every textbook draws liquid water running to the stomatal pore and evaporating there. Move the one control on this figure and watch that picture come apart.

            Fig L.1

            Two readings of the same anatomy

            A dicot leaf in cross-section. The anatomy does not change between the two settings. What changes is where the water turns into vapour.

            cuticle upper epidermis palisade mesophyll spongy mesophyll air space stoma stoma lower epidermis xylem phloem bundle sheath from the petiole one continuous column, never droplets under tension liquid water, all the way to the pore it evaporates only here liquid, through the cells vapour, through the air space at the sheath upper spongy beside the pore circle size = share of the evaporation vapour out

            On a narrow screen the diagram pans sideways: its labels are sized in the drawing's own units and shrinking them would make them unreadable.

            Which picture?
            00.10.2 °C
            Vapour share of Kox16%
            DERIVED · model
            Apoplastic bulk flow68%
            DERIVED · model
            Transmembrane19%
            DERIVED · model
            • The anatomy is identical in both settings. Only the reading of it changes, and only one of the two is what the models produce.
            • In the textbook setting the water stays liquid to the pore. Every drop of evaporation happens in one place.
            • In the model setting the air space is also a pipe. Raise the temperature difference and the vapour route carries more of the flow, so more of the evaporation moves back toward the bundle sheath.
            • Two tenths of a degree does this. Not two degrees.
            Check itsources, and what the model leaves outILLUSTRATIVE

            Cross-section drawn for this site; ILLUSTRATIVE: it is a schematic, not a micrograph, and it carries no scale. Pathway shares and the 16 to 65 % range are model output for 14 species from Buckley, John, Scoffoni & Sack 2015, Plant Physiology 168: 1616, doi:10.1104/pp.15.00731 Sources. The three evaporation sites (bundle sheath, upper spongy mesophyll, and surfaces immediately adjacent to open stomata) are theirs. The parallel-pathway argument is Buckley 2015, Plant Cell Environ 38: 7, doi:10.1111/pce.12372, and Rockwell, Holbrook & Stroock 2014, Plant Physiology 164: 1741, doi:10.1104/pp.114.236323. The three pathway shares are contributions in a parallel network. They do not sum to 100, and they are not a pie chart.

            Why evaporation has no single address

            Buckley put the argument in one paragraph, and it is the cleanest thing to hold on to. Two routes that start in the same place and end at the same place share the same potential gradient. Along most of that shared path there is nothing to drive a net phase change, so almost no evaporation happens there. It piles up at the ends.

            Which means the question is not where is the evaporating surface. It is how does the flow split. If a fifth of the water moves as vapour out of the , then a fifth of the evaporation happened at the bundle sheath. The anatomy decides the split: thick cell walls and an isothermal leaf push it toward the pore, thin walls and a warm leaf centre push it back toward the vein.

            The assumption underneath your gas-exchange data

            A LI-COR does not measure stomatal conductance. It infers it, and the inference assumes the air inside the leaf is saturated. If the interior actually sits at 80 % relative humidity, the driving gradient is smaller than assumed and stomatal conductance is underestimated by tens of per cent: about 29 % with the outside air at 30 % relative humidity and 40 % at 50 %, leaf and air at the same temperature DERIVED.

            PositionEvidence
            It is unsaturatedCernusak et al. 2024 Plant Cell Environ 47: 3685 (open access) review the reports of internal relative humidity below saturation and what they would imply.
            Not so fastRockwell 2024 New Phytol 244: 1812 shows patchy stomatal apertures can produce apparent unsaturation in the gas exchange calculation even where the air spaces are saturated. Blatt et al. 2026 New Phytol 250: 861 found Vicia faba stomata stayed open at 50 % internal humidity with no measurable fall in cell wall water potential.
            The physics problemAir at 80 % relative humidity, about the driest internal value estimated by Wong et al. 2022, is in equilibrium with a water potential of about −30 MPa at 20 °C (Ψ = 135 MPa × ln RH) DERIVED. Leaf water potentials sit within a few MPa of zero: hydrogel nanoreporters were built to read the physiological range of about 0 to −3 MPa (Jain et al. 2021). About ten times apart, and more for drier air.
            The sober readBuckley & Sack 2019 Am J Bot 106: 618: "we cannot yet embrace as fact the conclusion that the leaf airspaces are unsaturated." That caution has not been withdrawn.

            What this means for a vine in August

            In a compilation of 11 studies covering 34 species, outside-xylem or leaf hydraulic conductance fell by 9 to 99 per cent, 66 per cent on average, before the leaf xylem lost 12 per cent of its conductance or vein embolism began (Scoffoni et al. 2023, New Phytologist 239: 2099, open access).

            In that same table, the grapevine leaves had lost about 95 % of their hydraulic conductance before vein embolism began. The primary paper gives 94 % for Cabernet Sauvignon and 96 % for Chardonnay, with Chardonnay's midrib embolising at more negative water potentials. Those measurements come from Albuquerque et al. 2020 (J Exp Bot 71: 7286), the site author's own first-author study, carried into Scoffoni's compilation.

            So as a vine leaf dehydrates, most of its hydraulic decline happens , in the living tissue between the veins and the evaporating walls, before the veins take in air. The leaf's conductance falls first, and not because the xylem broke. The compilation describes that decline as dynamic and recoverable, not as death.

            Predict before you use Fig L.2. In a Cabernet Sauvignon leaf, the first midrib conduits take air near −1.25 MPa. How much of the leaf's hydraulic conductance is still there at that point?

            Your prediction
            Fig L.2

            Dry a grapevine leaf: the veins go last

            Leaf conductance, the stomata, the midrib, and the smaller veins, in the order they actually fail.

            0−1.4−2.8 MPa
            Cultivar

            • First the conductance, then the stomata, and the midrib only around turgor loss. Leaf hydraulic conductance halves near −0.3 MPa in both cultivars, stomatal conductance between −0.5 and −0.6. The first midrib conduits take air around −1.25 MPa, close to where the leaf loses turgor (−1.37 in Cabernet Sauvignon, −1.49 in Chardonnay). Values assume full conductance at 0 MPa (Table 2).
            • The veins fail from the top down. Embolism starts in the midrib. Secondary veins embolised in 8 of 23 leaves, always joined to midrib embolism. Tertiary veins in 4 of 23. Minor veins rarely: among the most dehydrated leaves, only one, at −2.8 MPa, had embolised minor-vein conduits.
            • Why the smallest veins hold. Their conduits are narrow, and the paper explains that with the rare pit hypothesis of Fig E.3: a narrow conduit has less wall, so fewer pits, so a smaller chance of one large enough to let air in. Short conduits and tougher pit membranes may add to it. That takes very high tension to breach.
            • The mesophyll cells shrink and the leaf thins before the midrib takes any air (Figs 2 and 3 of the paper). That is the outside-xylem tissue changing where you can see it. The next box asks whether the shrinking itself explains the lost conductance. It does not.
            Check itsources, and what the drawing leaves outMEASUREDDERIVEDILLUSTRATIVE

              The vein drawing is a vein-order schematic, not a grapevine leaf; grapevine leaves are palmately veined. How dark the gas-filled midrib gets tracks the count of embolised conduits, not their position. ILLUSTRATIVE

              The counterpoint from other species

              Optical imaging in four other species found embolism starting in the midrib and reaching the minor veins last, but reaching them, with no vein order spared (Brodribb et al. 2016 New Phytol 209: 1403). In Eucalyptus viminalis the vein-order P50 ran −3.35 MPa in the midrib, −3.80 in major veins and −4.07 in higher orders (Tonet et al. 2023 Plant Physiol 191: 1648). Optical methods cannot resolve single conduits and microCT resolves fewer leaves. "Almost never" is the grapevine microCT result, in the range of water potentials measured, not a law.

              If not the veins, then where does the conductance go?

              Into the living tissue between the vein xylem and the evaporating walls. Cell shrinkage alone does not explain it: from microCT images of dehydrating leaves, shrinking would by itself have raised outside-xylem conductance by 4 to 55 %, by shortening the path (Scoffoni et al. 2017 Plant Physiol 173: 1197). What the models needed was a steep fall in membrane permeability behind an apoplastic barrier (Scoffoni et al. 2017); in grapevine, a bundle sheath with a Casparian-like band, so that water has to cross its membranes (Albuquerque et al. 2020). Water crossing membranes means aquaporins. In Arabidopsis, silencing PIP1 aquaporins in the bundle sheath alone lowered leaf hydraulic conductance (Sade et al. 2014 Plant Physiol 166: 1609).

              An aquaporin that closes the stomata, not the pipes · preprint

              In a preprint, Albuquerque et al. knocked out the aquaporin VvPIP2;1 in Chardonnay with CRISPR. Under moderate drought the mutants kept their stomata open longer and photosynthesised more as leaf water potential became more negative, while leaf hydraulic conductance declined just as it did in the wild type. The authors' reading: PIP2;1 "induces earlier stomatal closure during dehydration while not modulating Kleaf" (Albuquerque et al. 2026, bioRxiv).

              Two honest edges. This is a preprint, not yet peer reviewed. And it cuts against the simple story in the box above: at least this one aquaporin acts on the stomata rather than on the leaf's hydraulic conductance. Which aquaporins, in which cells, set leaf hydraulic conductance is still open.

              Collapse: what is published, and what is not yet

              Under tension a conduit wall can buckle inward instead of letting air in. That has been seen, and it reverses. In red oak it happened in the minor veins, 4th to 7th order, between about −2 and −3 MPa, and recovered within minutes of rehydration, with no embolism in those conduits (Zhang et al. 2016 Plant Physiol 172: 2261). Pine needle tracheids collapse and recover (Cochard et al. 2004 Plant Physiol 134: 401), and so do the tracheids that run out sideways from the vein of a tropical conifer, Podocarpus grayi, which regained their shape within a week of rewatering (Brodribb & Holbrook 2005 Plant Physiol 137: 1139).

              In grapevine, the 2020 microCT work found no collapse of minor-vein conduits even at extreme dehydration. We found no published report of collapse in a grapevine midrib. Does collapse happen along the grapevine vein network? That is a question under study; numbers go here only once they are published.

              Check itwhat this stop assumes, and what it leaves out
              Not settled

              The 34-species result is not the last word. Bourbia & Brodribb 2024 (New Phytologist 242: 444, open access) measured leaf water potential continuously in intact, transpiring plants with an optical dendrometer and found that canopy conductance fell substantially as VPD rose while soil-to-leaf conductance stayed stable, in Arabidopsis and in Callitris. On that reading the decline is stomatal, not hydraulic.

              The disagreement is as much about method as about plants. Most of the 34-species compilation measures excised leaves, destructively, while they dehydrate. The stability result measures intact plants, non-destructively, transpiring in place. An excised dehydrating leaf and a transpiring one may not be the same object, and until someone measures the same leaf both ways the question stays open.

              What to fix in a generated figure

              Water in a conduit is a continuous column, never droplets. Droplets teach that water moves in packets, which makes cavitation impossible to understand.

              Evaporation happens at wet cell walls lining the air spaces, not at the pore. The pore is where vapour leaves, not where liquid becomes vapour.

              Label the bundle sheath. It is the gatekeeper between xylem and mesophyll and the best current candidate for where leaf hydraulic conductance is controlled.

              Go deeperreadings, methods, and what is still argued
              Not settled

              Where the bulk of the evaporation actually occurs is an open question. The models agree it clusters at the ends of the pathway. They disagree on which end, and they predict anything from mostly perivascular to mostly peristomatal depending on the leaf. No measurement has resolved it. The 2015 models of Buckley, John, Scoffoni and Sack (Plant Physiol 168: 1616) left it open, and we found no study since that has closed it.

              Two thresholds, side by side

              A Cabernet Sauvignon leaf has lost 94 % of its hydraulic conductance by about −1.25 MPa, where its veins begin to embolise. In a separate study of potted Cabernet Sauvignon, the stem's air-entry pressure was −1.22 MPa, calculated from the fitted vulnerability curve (Charrier et al. 2016). Different plants, labs and years, so read them as roughly equal: by about the time the stem begins to take air, the leaf's conductance has already collapsed, outside the xylem and reversibly. How a conduit fails takes the air-entry threshold apart; A season in one field is the next stop.

              Map › A season in one field

              Stop 7 of 7 · A season in one field

              A season in one field

              Everything on the earlier stops happens in one day. A field runs for months. Here the soil is a store that empties, the sky sets the rate it empties at, and the xylem keeps a record of the worst afternoon it ever had. Run four weeks and watch four numbers decide how the season ends.

              Before you start: five quantities that run the season
              The drying power of the air, in kPa. Here it is computed from the day's two temperatures and two humidities by FAO-56 Eq. 11 and Eq. 17, not typed in.
              Millimetres of water per metre of soil held between field capacity and −1.5 MPa. Multiply by root depth to get the size of the store.
              The retention curve that turns water content into soil water potential. Its four parameters are what makes a sandy loam and a clay loam behave differently.
              Percent loss of conductivity. In this model it accumulates from the worst midday the plant has had and never comes back.
              Solutes loaded into living cells, which makes πo more negative and moves the turgor loss point with it.

              Start hereLeave everything as it is and look at the four charts. Then switch the weather to a hot, dry day. The soil line passes −1.5 MPa on about day 20, the leaf line crosses the stem P12, P50 and P88 in order, and the loss of conductivity chart stops being flat. Then set irrigation to every seven days and see which of the four charts recovers.

              Fig F.1

              Run the season

              One crop, one soil, one kind of day, repeated. When does the store run out, and what breaks first?

              Crop
              Soil

              Weather, every day of the run

              VPD, computed from those four numbers

              Build your own day: five sliders

              A preset chip loads its own five numbers here, so you can start from a real day and change one thing. Move any slider and the chips switch to your day. The VPD above recomputes by the same FAO-56 arithmetic the presets use.

              5 °C2545 °C
              0 °C1530 °C
              20 %60100 %
              5 %50100 %
              10 %60110 %

              Sunshine is the fraction of a clear day's light that reaches the canopy, which is what the fog day preset turns down. The afternoon humidity cannot exceed the dawn humidity and the night temperature cannot reach the day temperature, so both sliders stop where the model would have clamped them anyway. The fog day preset is 45 % sunshine; the other two are 100 %.

              0.3 m0.91.5 m
              72845 days
              never71421 days
              • Soil water potential is drawn on a log scale, because the whole first week lives between −0.01 and −0.1 MPa and a linear axis hides it. The other three charts are linear.
              • The soil chart and the loss of conductivity chart answer two different questions. Set irrigation to every 21 days on a hot run and watch both on day 21: the soil jumps back to field capacity, while loss of conductivity stays near 100 %, because nothing in this model refills a conduit while the xylem is under tension.
              • On a hot run with no irrigation, watch the last week: once the soil reaches the model's floor of −3 MPa, the leaf goes far more negative than field vines are usually seen, and loss of conductivity jumps from a few per cent to nearly 100 % within days. That cliff comes from the model's floor and its single soil bucket, not from a measurement. MODEL PROPERTY
              • Drag the osmotic adjustment slider. The turgor loss point line moves; the loss of conductivity chart above it does not change by a single per cent.
              • Deepen the roots from 0.6 to 1.5 m on a hot run. Nothing about the plant changed. The store did.
              • Pick the hot, dry day, open the five sliders, and drop the afternoon humidity from 15 to 5 %. Then put it back and raise Tmax instead. Watch which one moves the VPD further.
              Check itsources, and what the model leaves outILLUSTRATIVEMEASURED

              Model output, not measurement: ILLUSTRATIVE This is a model built from measured parameters. The curves are computed; the constants they are computed from are listed below, each with the paper it came from, and several of them are marked illustrative because no measurement was found.

              Every constant in this figure, and where it comes from

              What this model leaves out

                VPD: FAO-56 Allen et al. 1998, Eq. 11, Eq. 12 and Eq. 17 Sources. Soil retention: van Genuchten 1980 Soil Sci Soc Am J 44: 892, with class-mean parameters from Carsel & Parrish 1988 Water Resour Res 24: 755 MEASURED Sources. Vulnerability curve: Pammenter & Vander Willigen sigmoid, with P12 = P50 + 49.81 ÷ s and P88 = P50 − 49.81 ÷ s; P88, not P80, is the field standard for the lethal end (Urli et al. 2013 Tree Physiol 33: 672). Grapevine stem P50 −1.73 MPa by microCT, Charrier et al. 2016; almond stem P50 −2.97 MPa by air injection, Álvarez-Maldini et al. 2022 MEASURED. πo: grapevine −1.23 MPa, Farolfi et al. 2025; almond −1.52 MPa, Álvarez-Maldini et al. 2022 MEASURED. Osmotic adjustment presets: Farolfi et al. 2025 for the two grapevine values, Jones & Turner 1978 Plant Physiol 61: 122 for sorghum MEASURED.

                Switch the weather to a fog day and leave it there for three weeks. What happens to the soil?

                Your prediction

                The soil is a store, and the sky sets the rate it empties

                Between field capacity and −1.5 MPa the soil holds an amount of water a root can actually get at. Here that is about 55 mm per metre in the sandy loam, 152 in the loam and 182 in the clay loam, worked out from the van Genuchten retention curve with Carsel and Parrish class means. Root depth multiplies it. A grapevine on 0.6 m of sandy loam is working from about 33 mm; the same vine on 1.5 m of clay loam has eight times that.

                What empties the store is not the plant's decision. It is the vapour pressure deficit, and the three day types here differ by a factor of fifteen at midday. Change nothing about the plant, change the sky, and the whole season changes shape.

                Temperature and humidity are not two independent levers on the same quantity. Raising Tmax raises e° steeply and exponentially, while lowering the humidity scales ea down in a straight line, so a hot humid day and a warm dry day can land on the same midday VPD by two different routes and then behave differently for the other twenty-three hours.

                Two days, both with a midday VPD of 3.07 kPa. Day A: 34 °C by day, 20 °C at night, humidity 90 % at dawn falling to 45 %. Day B: 27 °C by day, 10 °C at night, humidity 55 % at dawn falling to 9 %. Run each for fourteen days on loam. Which one takes more water out of the soil?

                Your prediction

                The cell can move its threshold; the conduit cannot move its own

                Two thresholds sit in this figure and they behave differently. The turgor loss point belongs to living cells, and loading solutes moves it: 0.9 MPa of osmotic adjustment takes a grapevine's turgor loss point from −1.40 MPa to −2.71 MPa, and the leaf holds its shape through afternoons that would have wilted it. P50 belongs to dead conduits, and it is thought to be set mainly by pit membrane structure. Solutes in a living cell do not change a pit membrane directly. P50 can still shift over a season as the xylem itself changes: in unirrigated grapevine leaves it became 0.71 MPa more negative from late May to late August, alongside seasonal changes in vessel size and pit membrane thickness (Sorek et al. 2021).

                One thing to watch for, because it is a property of this model rather than of plants: the stomata here respond to leaf water potential, not to turgor, so osmotic adjustment cannot feed back on transpiration at all. If stomata were driven by turgor, an adjusted plant would keep its stomata open longer, transpire more, and end the season with slightly more embolism, not less. The flat response you see is the model's assumption showing through, and it is worth arguing about.

                Cavitation is the event; embolism is the state, and this model does not undo it under tension

                Each day the model takes the worst midday leaf water potential, reads the percent loss of conductivity off the vulnerability curve, and keeps the highest value it has ever seen. Irrigating refills the soil. It does not refill a conduit, and the reason is narrower than "embolism is permanent": in intact vines, refilling was not observed while the xylem stayed under tension (Charrier et al. 2016).

                Refilling in grapevine is real. In Charrier et al. 2016, where xylem pressure stayed negative the change in conductivity loss was 0.02 ± 0.01 %; at the base of the plant, where pressure was +0.04 ± 0.01 MPa, it was −0.24 ± 0.12 %. Excised stems given water refilled within about an hour, and adding PEG slowed refilling substantially, so the driver is osmotic rather than root pressure (Knipfer et al. 2016 Plant Physiol 171: 1024). It also depends on the rootstock: repair was rapid in V. riparia and V. arizonica and negligible in V. champinii even after days (Knipfer et al. 2015 Plant Cell Environ 38: 1503).

                So in intact vines: night, the base of the plant, after rain. Refilling under bulk tension was not observed by Charrier et al. 2016 in intact vines, but it is still argued: Brodersen et al. 2010 imaged vessels refilling while the bulk xylem was under tension, which needs the refilling vessel to be hydraulically isolated from its neighbours. This model runs one midday value a day and never leaves tension, which is why its line is flat.

                Run a grapevine on sandy loam through a hot, dry spell until loss of conductivity passes 50 %, then irrigate. What comes back?

                Your prediction
                Fig F.2

                The day inside the day

                Every point on Fig F.1 is one number taken from a curve. Which number, and taken when?

                day 1the last day of the run
                • The crop, soil, weather and irrigation come from Fig F.1. Change them there and this day changes with them.
                • Leaf water potential is not a constant. It sits near the soil value before dawn, falls through the morning as the stomata open, bottoms out in the early afternoon, and climbs back after sunset. Fig F.1 plots only the bottom of that curve.
                • On a hot run, step through days 15 to 20 and watch the whole curve become more negative while its shape stays the same. The sky is doing the same thing every day; the soil underneath it is not.
                Check itsources, and what the model leaves outILLUSTRATIVE

                Hourly air temperature follows Parton & Logan 1981: a sine through the day and an exponential decay through the night. Sunrise and sunset are computed for 15 July at 36.664° N, 121.608° W by the NOAA solar position equations. Actual vapour pressure is held constant through the day, so VPD tracks temperature. Leaf water potential comes from a capacitance model stepped at 90 s, with stomatal closure fitted to Albuquerque et al. 2020 J Exp Bot 71: 7286 ILLUSTRATIVE MODEL OUTPUT · NOT DATA

                Does the same wet soil mean the same thing on every day?

                Everything above treats the soil as a store with one number on it. In 1962 Denmead and Shaw sank 136 containers of corn into an Iowa field, covered every soil surface with black plastic so that what they measured was transpiration and nothing else, watered each container to its own water content, and asked when the plants stopped keeping up with the air. The answer they published is that it depends on the air, and by a factor of forty.

                Fig F.3

                Does the same wet soil mean the same thing on every day?

                Three measured break points from 1962, the same experiment's turgor loss point below them, and one model curve computed here. The crop and soil come from Fig F.1.

                • The top panel is where transpiration falls behind. Their three points, read off the body of the paper, fall by a factor of forty across a four-and-a-half-fold range of demand. The blue curve is this model over a thirteen-fold range, and it is flat.
                • The bottom panel is the same experiment's Figure 6, and it is the stronger result. On a high-demand day the corn lost turgor at 34 % water content. Field capacity is 36 %. The soil was nearly full and the plant wilted anyway.
                • Change the crop in Fig F.1 and the blue curve moves. Change the soil or the root depth and it does not move at all. That is the first clue about what is wrong.
                They named the missing term in 1962, and it is still missing here

                Denmead and Shaw did not find this by accident. They predicted it from Philip and Gardner before they measured it: "the suction gradient between root and soil necessary to maintain a given rate of water uptake by the root, i.e., a given transpiration rate, is proportional to the rate of water uptake or the potential transpiration rate and inversely proportional to the capillary conductivity of the soil."

                That proportionality is exactly the term this model does not have. Soil-to-leaf conductance here is a function of bulk soil water potential alone, with no flux in it and no rhizosphere in it, so the gradient between the bulk soil and the root surface cannot grow when the plant pulls harder. The flat blue line is not evidence against them. It is the consequence of leaving out the one mechanism they identified sixty-four years ago, and you can watch it not happen.

                They drew the conclusion too: "the wilting point will also be expected to vary with soil moisture properties and with the potential transpiration rate." The same hole shows up a second way here. A sandy loam and a clay loam at the same bulk water potential conduct identically in this model, because the conductance function has no texture term either. In a real soil they do not.

                The observation that makes it real

                "whereas on days when the potential transpiration rate was high, plants were wilting at soil moisture contents less than the estimated turgor loss point, the same plants on a succeeding day with a lower potential transpiration rate would show no signs of wilting as long as the soil moisture content was greater than the estimated turgor loss point."

                Denmead & Shaw 1962, p. 388 MEASURED · PRIMARY. Same plants, same soil, one day apart. Wilting or not wilting, decided by the sky.

                Check itsources, and what the model leaves outILLUSTRATIVEMEASURED

                The demand ladder this figure runs

                DayVPD at midday, kPaPotential transpiration, mm d⁻¹Break point, MPa

                Three of the six days are the presets on this page. The other three are built between and beyond them by the same FAO-56 arithmetic, only to fill in the demand axis; they are constructions, not observations ILLUSTRATIVE. Potential transpiration is the model's own transpiration at field capacity, which is also how Denmead and Shaw defined theirs: the rate of well-watered controls on the same day, not a rate imposed on the plants. The break point is where transpiration has fallen 5 % below that. Their criterion was that the actual rate "fell significantly below" the potential rate, with no percentage stated, so the 5 % is ours and it moves the whole curve up or down if you change it.

                What the 1962 paper says, and what is still missing

                "For the most extreme conditions encountered in the experiment, when the potential transpiration rate was 6.4 mm. per day, the actual transpiration rate fell significantly below the potential rate when the average soil suction was only about 0.3 bar. For moderate potential transpiration rates of 3 to 4 mm. per day, the potential transpiration rate could be maintained until the average soil suction was about 2 bars. When the potential transpiration rate was only 1.4 mm. per day, this rate was maintained until the average soil suction was as much as 12 bars."

                Denmead & Shaw 1962, p. 387 MEASURED · PRIMARY

                WhatValueStanding
                Break point at 1.4 mm d⁻¹12 bar · −1.2 MPap. 387 PRIMARY
                Break point at 3 to 4 mm d⁻¹about 2 bar · −0.2 MPap. 387; plotted at 3.3, their labelled curve PRIMARY
                Break point at 6.4 mm d⁻¹about 0.3 bar · −0.03 MPap. 387 PRIMARY
                Transpiration rates at field capacity, the labelled curves1.4 · 2.0 · 3.3 · 4.1 · 5.6 · 6.4 mm 24 h⁻¹their Figs 3 and 4 PRIMARY
                Turgor loss point against demand23 % at 1.4 → 34 % above 6 mm d⁻¹their Fig. 6, summary p. 389 PRIMARY
                Three named days34.2 % · 28.2 % · 22.6 %p. 388; 30 July clear and dry, 13 Aug partly cloudy and humid, 5 Aug heavily overcast and humid PRIMARY
                The soilColo silty clay loam; field capacity 36 % by volume, 22 % by volume at 15 barp. 385 PRIMARY
                The plantscorn, a 4-plant hill per container, over a 5-week period commencing just prior to tasseling, inside a field-grown canopy in 40-inch hillsp. 385 to 386 PRIMARY
                The containers136 containers of 20 gallons, 18 in diameter and 24 in deep, sunk to ground level and spaced 40 in; 18 treatments, 7 controls and 11 variable soil moisture, replicated eight timesp. 385 to 386 PRIMARY
                Why every gram lost is transpirationthe soil surface was covered with black plastic film to prevent surface evaporationp. 386 PRIMARY
                Measurementneutron moisture meter down an access pipe in every container, read daily between 1600 and 1800; effective root depth 21 inp. 386 PRIMARY
                Treatmentsdepleted to 2.5, 5 and 15 bar; controls held below 0.5 barp. 386 PRIMARY
                Where and whenAmes, Iowa. Iowa Agricultural and Home Economics Experiment Station, Journal Paper J-4017, Project 1276; received 20 December 1961; part presented 16 November 1959, ASA annual meeting, Cincinnati; from Denmead's PhD thesis, Iowa State University, 1961p. 385 PRIMARY
                The x axis of their Figure 3volumetric soil moisture content, per centp. 387 PRIMARY
                Point-by-point coordinates of their curvesnonethe figures are scans and neither of us has digitised them NOT DIGITISED

                Two further results from the same paper, worth a line each. Their Figure 9 puts the demand axis on a standard weather calculation: transpiration at field capacity = 0.13 + 0.73 × open-water evaporation by Penman's method, r = 0.83. That is the road from this experiment to the FAO-56 depletion fraction. Their Figure 7 puts a price on the turgor loss point: reduction in dry weight = −8.6 + 14.5 × days below it, r = 0.85, and the slope of 14.5 g per hill per day sits close to the control plants' own growth rate of 13.9. Their conclusion: "once the soil moisture content is less than the turgor loss point, the plant virtually ceases to assimilate carbon dioxide." A day below the turgor loss point costs the whole day's growth, which is what the days-without-turgor tile in Fig F.1 is counting.

                This is a comparison across two different systems. Corn in sunken 20-gallon containers against a grapevine in 0.6 m of soil. Their numbers are not predictions for this crop, and the point of putting them side by side is the shape of the claim, not the values. Denmead & Shaw 1962 Agron J 54: 385, doi:10.2134/agronj1962.00021962005400050005x Sources. Ritchie 1973 Agron J 65: 893 Sources. Model curve ILLUSTRATIVE, parameters MEASURED, listed under Fig F.1.

                Denmead and Shaw measured the break point moving by a factor of forty, from 12 bar to 0.3 bar, as the demand of the day rose four and a half times. Before you read Fig F.3: in this model, how far does that break point move across a thirteen-fold range of demand?

                Your prediction

                Set osmotic adjustment to the sorghum value, 0.9 MPa, and run a hot, dry spell. Which two numbers change, and which one does not?

                Your prediction
                Check itwhat this stop assumes, and what it leaves out
                Open question · the humidity is an assumption

                Air temperature for the three day types comes from NOAA 1991 to 2020 normals for Salinas Municipal Airport and King City. The relative humidities do not. No station humidity normals were found for any Salinas Valley site, and the CIMIS daily records sit behind a keyed API that could not be read in this build. The four humidity numbers are stated assumptions, and every VPD on this page follows from them by arithmetic. Anyone with a free CIMIS account can pull the real hourly humidity for Salinas North station 116, drop it in, and the whole table regenerates. That is a real contribution and it takes an afternoon.

                Caveat · the plant-available water number is a model property

                Field capacity here is taken at −10 kPa rather than the −33 kPa convention. With the Carsel and Parrish mean parameters at −33 kPa, a sandy loam holds about 19 mm of plant-available water per metre, against 108 to 142 mm in the USDA measured tables: the two methods disagree by a factor of six in coarse soil. Taking −10 kPa narrows the gap and does not close it. Use these numbers to compare one soil with another inside this figure. Do not quote them for a field.

                Go deeperreadings, methods, and what is still argued

                Three positions, none of them retracted

                Denmead and Shaw 1962 put the break point at 12 bar when demand was 1.4 mm per day, at about 2 bar at 3 to 4, and at about 0.3 bar at 6.4. Corn, 136 sunken containers, Colo silty clay loam, Ames, Iowa, over five weeks from just before tasseling. The passage is quoted in full in the figure.

                Ritchie 1973 went to the field and found the opposite: "Evaporation rates were found to be practically independent of the soil water status for all existing conditions of potential evaporation… at least 80% of the extractable soil water was freely available to plant roots… serious errors are possible when using their results for predicting evaporation from corn plants growing under field conditions." Same crop, roots not confined to a pot.

                Tuzet, Perrier and Leuning 2003 built a mechanistic model that reproduces the direction and not the magnitude, and raised a third possibility: "it appears that the results of Denmead & Shaw (1962) can be explained if their graph is a composite derived from plants which started transpiration at different initial moisture contents." If that is right, part of the fan of curves is an artefact of how the experiment was assembled.

                None of the three has been retracted, and this page does not settle it. What survives all three is the direction of the mechanism, and it is standard practice: FAO-56 Chapter 8 turns it into the depletion fraction every irrigation schedule uses, p = pTable 22 + 0.04 (5 − ETc), held between 0.1 and 0.8, with ETc in mm per day. On a high-demand day the allowable depletion shrinks. Every schedule written in the Salinas Valley inherits the 1962 argument, whether or not the number behind it is right.

                Map › Test yourself

                Test yourself · three tiers

                Can you use it, or only say it?

                Five questions a round, three tiers. Know it is the words. Use it is the numbers, given to you. Question it is what plant physiologists actually do: decide whether a claim holds, and say so when the data cannot tell.

                How this works

                Pick an answer, then press Check. Every answer, right or wrong, comes with the reason and the paper behind it. Clear a tier with 4 of 5 and the next one opens. There is no timer: take as long as the question needs.

                Your scores stay in this browser. Nobody else sees them. Clearing site data, or switching browser, starts you over.

                Which part of the site?

                  Each item names the source its answer rests on. If you think an answer is wrong, you may be right: tell us.

                  Map › Symbols

                  Symbols and units

                  Every symbol on this site, its unit, and which way its sign runs. Tap any dotted term anywhere on the site to see its entry.

                  The one rule about negative numbers

                  −1.5 is more negative than −0.5. A leaf at −1.5 MPa holds its water more tightly, and is in more trouble, than a leaf at −0.5 MPa. Across a membrane, water moves toward more negative water potential; in the xylem it moves toward more negative pressure. On every chart here, 0 is at the top or the left and drier is down or to the right.

                  SymbolNameUnitMeaning

                  1 MPa = 10 bar = 145 psi = 1000 kPa. A soil tensiometer reading of 30 cbar is 30 kPa of tension, −0.03 MPa.

                  Map › Tell us what is wrong with this

                  Tell us what is wrong with this

                  This is a teaching site, built from papers and from models that are stated on every page. Two things would help most: where the science is wrong or out of date, and where a reader would get lost. Neither takes long to write and both change what the site teaches.

                  What happens to what you write

                  Nothing is stored on this page and nothing is sent from it. The form builds a message and hands it to your own mail client, and it only goes when you send it. If you would rather not use mail, copy the text and send it any way you like.

                  You are

                  Where did you have to read a sentence twice, or give up on a figure?

                  This is the one Caetano most wants answered. A wrong number, a misread paper, a mechanism stated more confidently than the evidence allows, a citation that does not say what the page claims it says. Be blunt.

                  Would you use this in your own teaching?

                  Nothing is stored on this page. The message only goes when you send it from your own mail client.

                  Map › Sources

                  Sources

                  Every number on this site comes from one of these. Badges on the figures say how: measured, derived by combining sources, or illustrative model constants.

                    Sources for the journey

                    The five plates of the journey cite the papers below. Each entry says what it supports and on which plate; the badge says how the number is used: measured published data, derived physics, illustrative a teaching constant, preprint not yet peer reviewed, open question the field has not settled it. Open the Evidence marker beside any claim on a plate for the figure or table.

                    1. Albuquerque, Momayyezi, Agüero et al. 2026, bioRxiv (not peer reviewed). doi:10.64898/2026.01.29.702672. preprint Used for: In grapevine, a CRISPR knockout of the PIP2;1 gene left the Kleaf vulnerability curve like the wild type; the knockouts kept higher gs and photosynthesis under moderate … In Water V, Membrane.
                    2. Albuquerque, Scoffoni, Brodersen, Buckley, Sack & McElrone 2020, Journal of Experimental Botany 71: 7286. doi:10.1093/jxb/eraa392. measured open question Used for: Grapevine stomatal conductance was down 80 % by a leaf water potential of about −1.2 MPa; half closure near −0.60 MPa is a fitted value still to be matched to the paper; The bundle sheath may do in the leaf what the endodermis does in the root and 3 more. In Water II, Plant, Water III, Organ, Water IV, Tissue.
                    3. Alleva et al. 2006, Journal of Experimental Botany 57: 609. doi:10.1093/jxb/erj046. measured open question Used for: In purified membranes, divalent cations at the N terminus, Ca2+ among them, favour the closed state (in vitro); Which wins in a leaf: raised Ca2+ closing PIPs, or Ca2+ needed for the blue light rise in Kleaf? and 1 more. In Water V, Membrane.
                    4. Álvarez-Maldini et al. 2022, Frontiers in Plant Science 13: 974050. doi:10.3389/fpls.2022.974050. measured Used for: Almond stomata are 90 % closed between −1.72 and −2.25 MPa, depending on cultivar; Almond stem P50 lies between −2.97 and −3.80 MPa, and stomata are 90 % closed between −1.72 and −2.25 MPa, by cultivar. In Water II, Plant, Water III, Organ.
                    5. As reviewed in Hartz et al. 2007, HortScience 42: 1681 (which cites Goto & Takakura 1992 and Frantz et al. 2004). doi:10.21273/hortsci.42.7.1681. measured open question Used for: In Salinas Valley romaine fields, tipburn was unrelated to soil or leaf calcium and was worst where fog cut transpiration in the final two weeks; Blowing air onto developing leaves reduced tipburn in controlled studies and 2 more. In Your Salinas afternoon.
                    6. Barta & Tibbitts 1986, Journal of the American Society for Horticultural Science 111: 413. doi:10.21273/JASHS.111.3.413. measured open question Used for: Enclosing young lettuce leaves to cut their transpiration lowered their calcium and raised tipburn; Because xylem delivery follows transpiration, enclosed, fast expanding inner leaves may receive less calcium than their new walls need. In Your Salinas afternoon.
                    7. Bartlett, Klein, Jansen, Choat & Sack 2016, PNAS 113: 13098. doi:10.1073/pnas.1604088113. open question Used for: Does wilting come before the first embolism? On average, yes: leaves lose turgor before stems lose half their conductivity. But the order varies with species and climate. In Water IV, Tissue.
                    8. Bartlett, Scoffoni & Sack 2012, Ecology Letters 15: 393. doi:10.1111/j.1461-0248.2012.01751.x. measured Used for: The turgor loss point moves more negative mainly when the osmotic potential at full turgor falls (osmotic adjustment). Wall stiffness mainly changes how much water the … In Water IV, Tissue.
                    9. Brodersen et al. 2013, Plant Physiology 161: 1820. doi:10.1104/pp.112.212712. measured Used for: In grapevine stems, embolism began in the vessels next to the pith and spread outward within sectors; only 16 of 629 vessel connections carried it sideways into a …; How to measure: vulnerability curve by X ray microCT. In Water III, Organ.
                    10. Brodribb & McAdam 2011, Science 331: 582. doi:10.1126/science.1197985. open question Used for: What closes stomata: the water signal, the hormone, or both? Ferns and lycophytes close passively; seed plants added ABA; falling turgor triggers ABA in angiosperm … In Water II, Plant.
                    11. Brodribb, Skelton, McAdam et al. 2016, New Phytologist 209: 1403. doi:10.1111/nph.13846. open question Used for: A contrasting view: optical imaging in four species found embolism in leaf veins tracking the decline of K-leaf; How to measure: vulnerability curve by the optical method. In Water IV, Tissue.
                    12. Bryla, Trout & Ayars 2010, HortScience 45: 1597 (central California weighing lysimeter). doi:10.21273/hortsci.45.11.1597. measured Used for: Lettuce basal crop coefficient about 0.95 at full cover; How to measure: reference evapotranspiration, ETo, from CIMIS. In Water I, Field.
                    13. Buckley et al. 2015, Plant Physiology 168: 1616. doi:10.1104/pp.15.00731. open question Used for: Models disagree on where the outside xylem resistance sits. Is the bundle sheath the control point? It is being tested. In Water IV, Tissue.
                    14. Buckley et al. 2017, Plant Physiology. doi:10.1104/pp.16.01605. derived Used for: Water evaporates from wet cell walls lining the air spaces: inner epidermis near the stomata, mesophyll, even the bundle sheath. Where most of it evaporates shifts with … In Water IV, Tissue.
                    15. Buckley 2019, New Phytologist 224: 21. doi:10.1111/nph.15899. open question Used for: What closes stomata: the water signal, the hormone, or both? Ferns and lycophytes close passively; seed plants added ABA; falling turgor triggers ABA in angiosperm … In Water II, Plant.
                    16. Buckley 2015, Plant, Cell and Environment 38: 7. doi:10.1111/pce.12372. derived Used for: Past the bundle sheath, most of the water moves through cell walls, a small share crosses membranes, and some moves as vapour through the air spaces. These shares are … In Water IV, Tissue.
                    17. Burlett et al. 2025, New Phytologist. doi:10.1111/nph.70052. Used for: How to measure: minimum leaf conductance, gmin.
                    18. Charrier et al. 2016, Plant Physiology 172: 1657. doi:10.1104/pp.16.01079. measured Used for: In intact Cabernet Sauvignon imaged by microCT, petiole P50 was −0.98 MPa, leaf −1.08 MPa and stem −1.73 MPa. When the stem reached its air-entry pressure, which the authors calculated from the …; How to measure: vulnerability curve by X ray microCT. In Water III, Organ.
                    19. Choat et al. 2012, Nature 491: 752. doi:10.1038/nature11688. measured Used for: Across 226 forest species, 70 % operate within 1 MPa of their stem P50 (a narrow hydraulic safety margin). In Water III, Organ.
                    20. Choat et al. 2010, Plant Cell and Environment. doi:10.1111/j.1365-3040.2010.02160.x. measured Used for: Air injection on short excised segments can overstate vulnerability in long vessel species; How to measure: vulnerability curve by air injection. In Water III, Organ.
                    21. Choat et al. 2016, Plant Physiology. doi:10.1104/pp.15.00732. Used for: How to measure: vulnerability curve by X ray microCT.
                    22. Choat & Pittermann 2009 New Phytol 182:557. doi:10.1111/j.1469-8137.2009.02847.x. derived measured Used for: Drought embolism spreads by air seeding: air is pulled from a gas filled conduit through the largest pore of a pit membrane once the pressure difference beats the …; A conduit embolises mainly by air seeding: air is pulled from a gas filled neighbour through the largest pore of the pit membrane. In conifer pits a thickened torus can … In Water III, Organ, Water IV, Tissue.
                    23. Choné et al. 2001, Annals of Botany 87: 477. doi:10.1006/anbo.2000.1361. measured Used for: Midday stem water potential, read on a bagged leaf in a pressure chamber, is a sensitive and less variable indicator of vine and tree water status; How to measure: stem and leaf water potential with a pressure chamber. In Water I, Field.
                    24. Cochard et al. 2013, Journal of Experimental Botany 64: 4779. doi:10.1093/jxb/ert193. measured Used for: Air injection on short excised segments can overstate vulnerability in long vessel species; How to measure: vulnerability curve by Cavitron (flow centrifuge) and 2 more. In Water III, Organ.
                    25. Cochard et al. 2004 Plant Physiol 134:401. doi:10.1104/pp.103.028357. open question Used for: Can a water filled conduit buckle and recover? Reversible wall collapse has been reported in pine needle tracheids, red oak minor veins and wheat leaf vessels. How often … In Water IV, Tissue.
                    26. Cochard et al. 2007, Plant Physiology 143: 122. doi:10.1104/pp.106.090092. measured Used for: Species decide how light moves Kleaf: from a 400 % rise in walnut to higher conductance in darkness in the Arabidopsis rosette. In Water V, Membrane.
                    27. Cuneo, Knipfer, Brodersen & McElrone 2016, Plant Physiology 172: 1669. doi:10.1104/pp.16.00923. measured Used for: In drying soil, fine root cortical cells collapse into air gaps (lacunae). Root conductance drops before root xylem embolism, and the damage does not recover; Grapevine fine roots reached root xylem P50 at −1.8 MPa, coarse roots at −3.5 MPa; cortical lacunae began near −0.6 MPa and cut root conductance first. In Water III, Organ.
                    28. Denmead & Shaw 1962, Agronomy Journal 54: 385. doi:10.2134/agronj1962.00021962005400050005x. measured Used for: How dry the soil can get before a crop falls behind depends on the weather: in container grown corn, transpiration fell below the potential rate at 0.3 bar soil suction … In Water I, Field.
                    29. Dimond 1966, Plant Physiology 41: 119 (Ohm analogy in tomato). doi:10.1104/pp.41.1.119. derived Used for: Water flow is the current and the water potential difference is the voltage: flow = ΔΨ ÷ R. More resistance at the same pull means less flow. In Water II, Plant.
                    30. Duursma et al. 2019, New Phytologist. doi:10.1111/nph.15395. illustrative Used for: With stomata shut a leaf still loses water: through the cuticle and through stomata that do not close fully. Together these are the minimum conductance, gmin; How to measure: minimum leaf conductance, gmin. In Water II, Plant.
                    31. Frick et al. 2013, FEBS Letters 587: 989. doi:10.1016/j.febslet.2013.02.038. measured Used for: A low cytosolic pH protonates a conserved histidine on loop D and holds the channel shut. This is one reason flooded, oxygen starved roots take up less water. In Water V, Membrane.
                    32. Garen & Michaletz 2024, New Phytologist 245: 1911. doi:10.1111/nph.20346. measured Used for: Expert depth: as leaves heat up, the share of gmin that goes through the cuticle rises. In Water II, Plant.
                    33. Grunwald et al. 2022 Plant Cell 34:2328. doi:10.1093/plcell/koac089. measured Used for: Blue light, sensed by phototropins in the bundle sheath, activates the AHA2 H+ ATPase there; the xylem sap acidifies, bundle sheath Pf rises and Kleaf rises; Species decide how light moves Kleaf: from a 400 % rise in walnut to higher conductance in darkness in the Arabidopsis rosette. In Water V, Membrane.
                    34. Grunwald et al. 2021, Plant Journal 106: 301. doi:10.1111/tpj.15235. measured Used for: Blue light, sensed by phototropins in the bundle sheath, activates the AHA2 H+ ATPase there; the xylem sap acidifies, bundle sheath Pf rises and Kleaf rises. In Water V, Membrane.
                    35. Herrera et al. 2022, Plant Journal 109: 804. doi:10.1111/tpj.15591. measured Used for: In grapevine, osmotic adjustment through the season moves the turgor loss point more negative, and K-leaf vulnerability and stomatal closure move with it. In Water IV, Tissue.
                    36. Hochberg, Albuquerque, Rachmilevitch et al. 2016, Plant, Cell and Environment 39: 1886. doi:10.1111/pce.12688. measured open question Used for: Grapevine petiole P50 is −1.54 MPa and stem P50 is −1.90 MPa; About half the petiole vessels were embolised at −1.6 MPa, while few stem vessels were and 2 more. In Water III, Organ.
                    37. Hochberg et al. 2017, Plant Physiology 174: 764. doi:10.1104/pp.16.01816. measured Used for: In dehydrating grapevine, complete stomatal closure came several days before embolism appeared in leaves or stem. In Water III, Organ.
                    38. Hochberg, Rockwell, Holbrook & Cochard 2018, Trends in Plant Science 23: 112. doi:10.1016/j.tplants.2017.11.002. measured Used for: How far a vine lets its leaf Ψ fall depends on soil and weather, not only on the variety. In Water II, Plant.
                    39. Kaack et al. 2021, New Phytologist 230: 1829. doi:10.1111/nph.17282. derived Used for: D in ΔP = 4T ÷ D is an equivalent pore size: real pit membranes are 3D, with constrictions set by membrane thickness, and sap surfactants lower surface tension in the … In Water III, Organ.
                    40. Kerstiens 1996, Journal of Experimental Botany 47: 1813. doi:10.1093/jxb/47.12.1813. illustrative Used for: With stomata shut a leaf still loses water: through the cuticle and through stomata that do not close fully. Together these are the minimum conductance, gmin; How to measure: minimum leaf conductance, gmin. In Water II, Plant.
                    41. Knipfer et al. 2016 (all Plant Physiology). doi:10.1104/pp.126.1.27. open question Used for: Can grapevine refill embolised vessels while the xylem is under tension? The evidence conflicts; How to measure: vulnerability curve by MRI. In Water III, Organ.
                    42. Knipfer et al. 2016 (all Plant Physiology). doi:10.1104/pp.16.00136. open question Used for: Can grapevine refill embolised vessels while the xylem is under tension? The evidence conflicts; How to measure: vulnerability curve by bench dehydration. In Water III, Organ.
                    43. Maes & Steppe 2012, Journal of Experimental Botany 63: 4671. doi:10.1093/jxb/ers165. measured Used for: Canopy temperature from a thermal camera tracks stomatal closure; reflectance indices such as NDVI track greenness and leaf area and respond later. In Water I, Field.
                    44. Martorell et al. 2015, Physiologia Plantarum. doi:10.1111/ppl.12253. measured Used for: In grapevine, osmotic adjustment through the season moves the turgor loss point more negative, and K-leaf vulnerability and stomatal closure move with it. In Water IV, Tissue.
                    45. Maurel et al. 2015, Physiological Reviews 95: 1321. doi:10.1152/physrev.00008.2015. measured Used for: Water moves fastest and protons are blocked, but depending on isoform plant aquaporins also carry some small neutral molecules and gases, such as CO2, H2O2 and boric … In Water V, Membrane.
                    46. Murata et al. 2000, Nature 407: 599. doi:10.1038/35036519. measured Used for: Why water passes and protons do not: the pore narrows to about 3 Å over one residue, so water moves in single file and protons are excluded. In Water V, Membrane.
                    47. Naor & Cohen 2003, HortScience 38: 547. doi:10.21273/hortsci.38.4.547. measured Used for: Midday stem water potential, read on a bagged leaf in a pressure chamber, is a sensitive and less variable indicator of vine and tree water status; How to measure: stem and leaf water potential with a pressure chamber. In Water I, Field.
                    48. Naseer et al. 2012, PNAS 109: 10101. doi:10.1073/pnas.1205726109. measured Used for: The Casparian strip is a band of lignin in the radial walls of the endodermis. It blocks the wall route, so water and solutes must cross a membrane. Suberin lamellae … In Water III, Organ.
                    49. Nyblom et al. 2009, Journal of Molecular Biology 387: 653. doi:10.1016/j.jmb.2009.01.065. measured Used for: In purified membranes, divalent cations at the N terminus, Ca2+ among them, favour the closed state (in vitro). In Water V, Membrane.
                    50. Ohtsuka, Sack & Taneda 2018, Plant, Cell and Environment 41: 342, as quoted in Scoffoni et al. 2023. doi:10.1111/pce.13087. measured Used for: Species whose bundle sheath walls are lignified had more than 50 % lower K-ox and K-leaf. In Water IV, Tissue.
                    51. Palzkill & Tibbitts 1977, Plant Physiology 60: 854. doi:10.1104/pp.60.6.854. measured Used for: Enclosed cabbage plants that were not transpiring still moved calcium into their leaves, through root pressure flow; covered leaves on partly enclosed plants, with no … In Your Salinas afternoon.
                    52. Pammenter & Vander Willigen 1998, Tree Physiology 18: 589. doi:10.1093/treephys/18.8-9.589. illustrative Used for: The S shaped vulnerability curve. In Water III, Organ.
                    53. Peters & Choat 2025 Plant Cell Environ 48:2162 to 2177 (online Nov 2024). doi:10.1111/pce.15249. open question Used for: Do distal organs reach P50 before the stem? Grapevine petioles did; twelve Australian tree species did not; Does wilting come before the first embolism? On average, yes: leaves lose turgor before stems lose half their conductivity. But the order varies with species and climate. In Water III, Organ, Water IV, Tissue.
                    54. Pittermann et al. 2005, Science 310: 1924. doi:10.1126/science.1120479. measured Used for: A conduit embolises mainly by air seeding: air is pulled from a gas filled neighbour through the largest pore of the pit membrane. In conifer pits a thickened torus can … In Water IV, Tissue.
                    55. Prado et al. 2013, Plant Cell 25: 1029. doi:10.1105/tpc.112.108456. measured Used for: Light does not always raise leaf hydraulic conductance. In Arabidopsis rosettes conductance was higher in darkness, and diphosphorylation of AtPIP2;1 at Ser280 and …; Species decide how light moves Kleaf: from a 400 % rise in walnut to higher conductance in darkness in the Arabidopsis rosette. In Water V, Membrane.
                    56. Prado et al. 2019, Plant Cell 31: 417. doi:10.1105/tpc.18.00804. measured Used for: Expert depth: Arabidopsis rosette conductance follows a circadian rhythm with a midday peak; phosphorylation of AtPIP2;1 at Ser280 and Ser283 is necessary but not … In Water V, Membrane.
                    57. Pratt et al. 2020, Tree Physiology. doi:10.1093/treephys/tpz092. Used for: How to measure: vulnerability curve by the optical method.
                    58. Ritchie 1973, Agronomy Journal 65: 893. doi:10.2134/agronj1973.00021962006500060014x. measured Used for: A methods fight: in field corn on a weighing lysimeter, evaporation was practically independent of soil water status, with at least 80 % of extractable water freely … In Water I, Field.
                    59. Rodrigues et al. 2017, PNAS 114: 9200. doi:10.1073/pnas.1704754114. measured Used for: Water moves fastest and protons are blocked, but depending on isoform plant aquaporins also carry some small neutral molecules and gases, such as CO2, H2O2 and boric … In Water V, Membrane.
                    60. Sack & Holbrook 2006, Annual Review of Plant Biology 57: 361. doi:10.1146/annurev.arplant.56.032604.144141. measured Used for: Leaves are a large part of the whole plant resistance: at least 30 %, and K-leaf varies more than 65 fold across species. In Water II, Plant.
                    61. Sack & Scoffoni 2012, Journal of Visualized Experiments. doi:10.3791/4179. Used for: How to measure: stomatal conductance from transpiration.
                    62. Sade et al. 2014, Plant Physiology 166: 1609. doi:10.1104/pp.114.248633. measured Used for: Silencing PIP1 aquaporins only in the bundle sheath lowered Kleaf and the Pf of bundle sheath and mesophyll cells. In Water V, Membrane.
                    63. Schenk et al. 2017, Plant Physiology. doi:10.1104/pp.16.01039. derived Used for: D in ΔP = 4T ÷ D is an equivalent pore size: real pit membranes are 3D, with constrictions set by membrane thickness, and sap surfactants lower surface tension in the … In Water III, Organ.
                    64. Scoffoni, Albuquerque, Brodersen et al. 2017, Plant Physiology 173: 1197. doi:10.1104/pp.16.01643. measured Used for: Across eight species, vulnerability outside the xylem explained 75 to 100 % of the decline of K-leaf as leaves dried. In Water IV, Tissue.
                    65. Scoffoni, Albuquerque, Buckley & Sack 2023, New Phytologist 239: 2099 (Fig. 2). doi:10.1111/nph.19069. derived measured Used for: At a fixed transpiration rate, changing one resistance moves water potential only downstream of that resistance; Water evaporates from wet cell walls lining the air spaces: inner epidermis near the stomata, mesophyll, even the bundle sheath. Where most of it evaporates shifts with … and 3 more. In Water II, Plant, Water IV, Tissue.
                    66. Scoffoni et al. 2008, Plant, Cell and Environment 31: 1803. doi:10.1111/j.1365-3040.2008.01884.x. measured Used for: Species decide how light moves Kleaf: from a 400 % rise in walnut to higher conductance in darkness in the Arabidopsis rosette. In Water V, Membrane.
                    67. Scoffoni, Sack & Ort 2017, Journal of Experimental Botany 68: 4479 (database of 310 species). doi:10.1093/jxb/erx252. measured Used for: Across 56 studies and 310 species, K-leaf fell by 40 % on average before the leaf wilted (range 0 to 96 %). In Water IV, Tissue.
                    68. Scoffoni, Vuong, Diep, Cochard & Sack 2014, Plant Physiology 164: 1772. doi:10.1104/pp.113.221424. measured Used for: As leaves dry, cells shrink and lose contact; across 14 species the early decline of K-leaf tracked leaf thickness shrinkage. In Water IV, Tissue.
                    69. Shatil-Cohen, Attia & Moshelion 2011, Plant Journal. doi:10.1111/j.1365-313x.2011.04576.x. measured Used for: ABA fed through the xylem lowered K-leaf and bundle sheath Pf, while ABA smeared on the blade closed stomata without lowering K-leaf within 2 to 3 h; The ABA valve: ABA fed through the xylem lowered Kleaf and bundle sheath Pf, while ABA put on the leaf blade closed the stomata without lowering Kleaf. ABA also inhibits … In Water IV, Tissue, Water V, Membrane.
                    70. Teaching split. Calibration check: in wheat the leaf held 26 to 33 % of whole plant resistance (Corso et al. 2020, Plant, Cell and Environment 43: 854). doi:10.1111/pce.13722. illustrative open question Used for: How the plant’s resistance is shared between root, stem, petiole, leaf xylem and the path outside the xylem; Can a water filled conduit buckle and recover? Reversible wall collapse has been reported in pine needle tracheids, red oak minor veins and wheat leaf vessels. How often … and 1 more. In Water II, Plant, Water IV, Tissue, Water V, Membrane.
                    71. Tetens form as given by Murray 1967, Journal of Applied Meteorology 6: 203; FAO 56 Eq. 11. doi:10.1175/1520-0450(1967)006<0203:otcosv>2.0.co;2. derived Used for: Vapour pressure deficit is the saturation vapour pressure at leaf temperature minus the actual vapour pressure of the air; it sets how hard the air pulls; How to measure: VPD from air temperature and humidity. In Water I, Field.
                    72. Tixier et al. 2014, Annals of Botany 114: 325. doi:10.1093/aob/mcu109. derived Used for: Drought embolism spreads by air seeding: air is pulled from a gas filled conduit through the largest pore of a pit membrane once the pressure difference beats the … In Water III, Organ.
                    73. Torne-Srivastava et al. 2024, Plant Physiology 195: 2635. doi:10.1093/plphys/kiae226. measured open question Used for: Which wins in a leaf: raised Ca2+ closing PIPs, or Ca2+ needed for the blue light rise in Kleaf?; The ABA valve: ABA fed through the xylem lowered Kleaf and bundle sheath Pf, while ABA put on the leaf blade closed the stomata without lowering Kleaf. ABA also inhibits … In Water V, Membrane.
                    74. Törnroth-Horsefield et al. 2006, Nature 439: 688. doi:10.1038/nature04316. measured Used for: A plant PIP aquaporin is a tetramer: four monomers, each with its own water pore. In the closed state loop D folds over the pore from the cytosolic side; to open, it …; A low cytosolic pH protonates a conserved histidine on loop D and holds the channel shut. This is one reason flooded, oxygen starved roots take up less water. In Water V, Membrane.
                    75. Tournaire-Roux et al. 2003 Nature 425:393. doi:10.1038/nature01853. measured Used for: A low cytosolic pH protonates a conserved histidine on loop D and holds the channel shut. This is one reason flooded, oxygen starved roots take up less water. In Water V, Membrane.
                    76. van den Honert 1948 Discuss Faraday Soc 3:146 ('Water transport in plants as a catenary process'). doi:10.1039/df9480300146. derived Used for: Water flow is the current and the water potential difference is the voltage: flow = ΔΨ ÷ R. More resistance at the same pull means less flow. In Water II, Plant.
                    77. Verdoucq et al. 2008 Biochem J 415:409. doi:10.1042/bj20080275. measured open question Used for: In purified membranes, divalent cations at the N terminus, Ca2+ among them, favour the closed state (in vitro); Which wins in a leaf: raised Ca2+ closing PIPs, or Ca2+ needed for the blue light rise in Kleaf?. In Water V, Membrane.
                    78. Wheeler et al. 2013, Plant Cell and Environment. doi:10.1111/pce.12139. Used for: How to measure: vulnerability curve by bench dehydration.
                    79. Worthington & Lee 2026, Journal of Experimental Botany 77: 2177. doi:10.1093/jxb/erag008. measured Used for: Plasmodesmata are not fixed open pores. Callose laid down at their necks narrows them, and its breakdown reopens them, in a signal specific way. In Water IV, Tissue.
                    80. Yaaran et al. 2023, Plant Physiology 193: 1349. doi:10.1093/plphys/kiad372. measured Used for: ABA fed through the xylem lowered K-leaf and bundle sheath Pf, while ABA smeared on the blade closed stomata without lowering K-leaf within 2 to 3 h. In Water IV, Tissue.
                    81. Zhang et al. 2016 Plant Physiol 172:2261. doi:10.1104/pp.16.01191. open question Used for: Can a water filled conduit buckle and recover? Reversible wall collapse has been reported in pine needle tracheids, red oak minor veins and wheat leaf vessels. How often … In Water IV, Tissue.

                    Physics, definitions and teaching constants

                    These carry no paper because they are physics or a stated teaching choice.

                    • California Code of Regulations, Title 23, Model Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance, Appendix A (CIMIS station averages, inches per month), as used in the original Water Path. measured In Water I, Field.
                    • Definition of water potential. derived In Water II, Plant.
                    • Definition of water potential (house identity, Numbers Ledger). derived In Water IV, Tissue.
                    • Kelvin relation (physical chemistry); no paper needed. derived In Water I, Field.
                    • Literature search for Lactuca sativa xylem vulnerability, no result. illustrative In Water III, Organ.
                    • No published value found for Lactuca sativa. illustrative In Water II, Plant.
                    • Physics: ρ g h with ρ = 1000 kg m⁻³ and g = 9.8 m s⁻². derived In Water II, Plant.
                    • Teaching constant; no published inner to outer ratio was found. illustrative In Your Salinas afternoon.
                    • Teaching preset, not a weather record. illustrative In Water I, Field.
                    • Ψair = (R T ÷ Vw) ln(RH ÷ 100), the Kelvin relation. derived In Water II, Plant.

                    What was checked for colour vision, and what it means for you

                    Every colour on this site was simulated for protanopia, deuteranopia and tritanopia with the severity-1.0 matrices of Machado, Oliveira & Fernandes (2009) and the pairs that share a figure were measured in CIE Lab. No two colours that appear together fall below ΔE 12. Text contrast follows WCAG 2.1: body text is at least 4.5:1 against its background in both themes, and no word is written in the colour of the thing it names, because the swatch or the line already carries that.

                    If any of this fails for you, the feedback form asks what was hard to follow. Say so there and it gets fixed.